11 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting, educating, and fast moving, October 12, 2007
This review is from: God's Gold: A Quest for the Lost Temple Treasures of Jerusalem (Hardcover)
I picked up this book to read a man's personal quest and theory about the Lost Temple Treasure. That is exactly what I got and enjoyed every bit of it. I have a degree in History and professionaly have found that Kingsley has done a lot of research and investigating- that's worth a lot.
If you are picking up this book because you think that the end will lead you to the POT OF GOLD, then don't bother, because anyone in this field knows that we do not know what happened to the treasure- you should stick with Indiana Jones for a feel good ending. However if you want to see a learned man obsessed with the past (as I have personally been there before) and taking all the steps that he knows to reconstruct a time gone by, than by all means enjoy this trip to far away lands in far away times-and who knows, maybe he's got it right.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A Nice Read, Not Much New Under the Sun Though, September 14, 2010
Sean Kingsley has written a pleasant, easily readable book with lots of promise, but very little payoff. It is written in a very self-indulgent style, but not in an offensive way. For those with a deeper knowledge of history, there will be almost nothing new, but he does cross many different time periods nicely and weaves the time-line of the temple treasures possible journey in a very accessible fashion. For those with less of a background in the pertinent histories I think you will find enough historical facts and information from the post biblical period of Jerusalem, through the destruction of Jerusalem in 70 C.E., with relevant discussions of the Dead Sea scrolls, and Imperial Rome. His Journey will also take you to the early Byzantine era and up to the start of the Muslin ear in the Levant. There the journey rather spectacularly ends, with a rather weak conclusion and false idealistic rationalization.
Kingsley, narrates his travels to many different lands were the Temple treasures may have lain themselves, but as you go with him the reader is almost always left with the feeling that the journey was unnecessary and simply justification to find filler for the book. . The author tries to imply that his journeys break new ground and revelations about the Temple treasure, but each time he then suddenly finds a historical passage from ancient historians that one could easily find on Google, Wikipedia or the local library that tell him where to go next
For example, in one chapter Kingsley goes to Rome and visits many important archaeological sites so that he can get his mind around where the Temple treasures may have been taken by conquerors and victors. The writing is crisp and the descriptions of ancient Rome are informative and accurate, but in the end he simple sites Josephus's writings form his book, "The Jewish War", 7.158-161, which tell him that the Temple treasures were taken to the Temple of Peace by Vespasian and Titus. All his travels essentially have taken him back to the primary historical source, with no new information to further expound on the validity of Josephus. This pattern of travel, visit the important archaeological sites to dig for the truth, and then returning to easily accessible historical sources for the answer (and then taking these sources for fact) are repeated over and over throughout the book.
Still I must admit that I enjoyed Kingsley's style and easy way with bringing history to the written page, but there isn't much new here and his conclusions are as stated above, rather disappointing and self-serving. Towards the end of the book his attempts to imply the danger he is in by exploring the subject matter at hand, or by his travel to easily accessible regions of the West Bank are almost comical. In many ways this book is like the magazine, Minerva, where Kingsley has worked as managing editor. Filled with promise and glitz, lots to look at, but very little for the history buff who wants to look deeper.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
a treasure hunt without treasure, June 26, 2011
Kingsley takes a very educated and intellectual look at a quest that has obsessed both scholars and treasure hunters for centuries, the quest for the gold treasures from the temple of Jerusalem. Kingsley, an archaeologist with a long history of digs and scholarly investigations, brings all of his education and experience to bear on the topic, testing out a number of hypotheses as to where the gold ended up. It's a fascinating story, rich in history, travel details and the real-life details of what archaeologists actually did without the Indiana-Jones derring-do gloss. That the tale ultimately ends flat has nothing to do with the writing and everything to do with the fact that this mystery many never be solved.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No