From Publishers Weekly
British author Allen (
Soldier Sahibs) argues persuasively that violent Islamic extremism isn't as new as we might think, but unfortunately, his book doesn't do much to explain the phenomenon. Carefully drawing distinctions between mainstream Islam and the fanaticism that spawned al-Qaeda (which he calls "as much a threat to Islam as to the West"), Allen goes back to the 18th-century founding of Wahhabism, a strain of Islam fostered in the Arabian desert that now serves as the Saudi state religion. Fixated on removing any hint of deviation from their interpretation of Muhammad's teachings, violent Wahhabists have traditionally killed more Muslims than non-Muslims. A Central Asia expert, Allen focuses on the form of Wahhabism that developed against the backdrop of waning British imperialism in that area, gradually leading up to Osama bin Laden's arrival. But his rapid-fire account is littered with names and battles, explaining little about how an ideology always rejected by most Muslims, and whose proponents were nearly annihilated on many occasions, managed to survive so spectacularly. Nor does he explain why Wahhabists' anger has shifted from supposed infidels in their midst to citizens of the West.
(Sept.) Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
--This text refers to the
Hardcover
edition.
Review
"A story of intransigence, hatred of modernity, millennial dreams, bloody massacres and invariably disappointed hopes." --
The Independent, 3/3/06"Allen is a gifted narrative historian." --
Book Review Digest, 3/1/07"Allen lifts his narrative off the pages of history and into the latest headlines." --
The Agonist, 6/5/06"Allen tells his complex story with concision, insight and wide-ranging vision
[and] throws new, if uncomfortable, light on our world." --
London Sunday Times, 2/19/06"It is filled with understanding of past events, key to understanding modern jihad." --
California Bookwatch, November 2006"Of use to those seeking to understand the origins and growth of Islamic extremism." --
Kirkus Reviews, 7/15/06"Offers a moving account of the famous [Sepoy] revolt
Allens work should be welcomed by Muslim readers." --
Asharq Alawsat, 5/22/06"Outstanding...Provides excellent groundwork for a beginning of enlightenment." --
The Advocate, 9/23/2006"With a scholar's eye for detail and a popular historian's flair for the dramatic, [Allen] does a remarkable job." --
(Infodad.com, 10/12/2006)"[A] valuable narrative of the growth of a radical cult and their ideology." --
Military.com, 10/3/2006
--This text refers to the
Hardcover
edition.
See all Editorial Reviews