113 of 171 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Symptomatic of Deeper Problems -, December 12, 2009
This review is from: Going Rouge: An American Nightmare (Paperback)
"Going Rouge" is closer to the truth than "Going Rogue," depicting Sarah Palin as a conservative fundamentalist Christian flaunting ignorance as a virtue - 'America's nightmare.' (Given her stance on global warming, 'world's nightmare' might even be appropriate.) On the other hand, she's not that much different from Bush '43 and some of the other leading Republican candidates. Her approval rating among Republicans stood at 70% before the Huckabee pardon scandal (Maurice Clemmons - 4X cop killer), and is most likely higher now.
The book is actually a collection of more than 50 short essays written about Palin during the campaign - as a result, the material is generally dated. (Example: "Going Rouge" credits Palin with not getting into the Obama 'birther' controversy, while since it was written she has.) In addition, the essays do not cover well her early controversial days as Mayor of Wassila. Worse yet, the material is superficial and probably no more credible than Palin's "Going Rogue." Readers would do better to read the accountings within the Anchorage Daily News about her various ethics challenges.
Whether one likes or dislikes Sarah Palin, however, is not that important. A more significant issue is "Why do personages like Sarah Palin or Bush '43 appeal to so many in the U.S.?" My suspicion is that it derives from our historical values of personal freedom and limitations on government, coupled with educational laziness that easily translates into simple solutions consistent with those values. On the other hand, the general inability of academics or the educated elite to 'solve' basic economic, business, education, and social problems doesn't help them garner respect either; neither do dogmatic and authoritarian religions, the daily avalanche of confusing half-truths promulgated by various position advocates, and the near domination of dogmatic party-line responses to issues instead of pragmatic, data-driven analyses.
Bottom Line: The names don't matter. Whether its Sarah Palin, George W. Bush, Glenn Beck, Rush Limbaugh, or Joe-the-Plumber - someone with similar simple-minded 'solutions' will crop up to lead the right because its in our collective DNA. Meanwhile, the left's 'thinking' and solutions usually aren't much better. Thus, when combined with arcane Senate rules, gerrymandering, and the domination of elections by monied interests, major problems such as global warming, terrorism, oil shortages, out-of-line expenditures for health care, defense, drug control, government overhead, and education (vs. other developed nations), unfunded Social Security liabilities, deteriorating infrastructure, and illegal immigration all go unresolved. The U.S. political system is unable to cope with the complications of the 21st century.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
27 of 42 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Bought for my 77 year old mom, May 24, 2010
This review is from: Going Rouge: An American Nightmare (Paperback)
I bought this for my mom, in South Carolina, for Christmas. She thought it was the other one when she opened and she is very polite but was happy when I pointed out is was Going Rouge. My parents are the extinct type of republicans - socially liberal and fiscally conservative. They held their noses and voted for McCain/Palin in the last election mostly because they didn't know anything about Palin. I spoke with my mom yesterday and she is in the middle of reading the book and commented that it is frightening that this woman was actually on the ticket. This is a great book for rational readers who haven't yet been exposed to the truth about Palin.
We can only hope that Palin runs in 2012 - but unfortunately, I think she's just being a tease to milk more $$$ from her groupies.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
49 of 78 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Good stuff!, December 12, 2009
This review is from: Going Rouge: An American Nightmare (Paperback)
This isn't a single, discursive analysis of the Palin phenomenon, but a collection of essays and articles that appeared at some point in that extraordinary arc, the Palin political parabola. It is a graph plot that goes from nothing - (0,0) to a high point at the Republican convention, then the rapid descent on the y-axis as her amazing unsuitability for any major post became clear. However, just when you think her vertical coordinate must be about zero, she manages to slide into an asymptotic approach and indeed even turn the graph upwards again, at least in terms of staying in the public eye.
The problem with selling the book, I suppose, is that those rational beings who have already read about as much as they can stomach about the lipsticked pit bull, may feel it unnecessary to read much of the same again. To them I say - no, get the book, it's well worth it. You are sure to find new nuggets of information about Palin's dishonesty, aggression, and also skill in playing to the lowest common denominator of the public: a section that has never been quite so clearly delineated as by her supporters. They are a vivid reminder that this is the only country that once actually had a political party called the "Know-Nothings." She plays on a sort of rube distrust of those pointy-headed intellectuals who have the nerve to think that in government, knowledge and intelligence may be more necessary than knowing how to fix a diesel engine or shoot a 12-bore. Not that there is anything wrong with the latter, but to interact with leaders on the world stage, a little more is required.
I recommend this book for the diversity of writing and styles. Enjoy that wild man Matt Taibbi's ferocious rant (he says that watching the convention speech was like seeing Gidget addressing the Reichstag!) and Juan Cole's fascinating comparison of Palin to Ahmadinejad. (Did that get your attention? Thought so. So it should.)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No