| |||||||||||||||
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
33 of 34 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Poignant Portrait of an Embattled Financier and His Times,
By Melvin Sico "melvinsico" (Singapore) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Gold and Iron (Hardcover)
The first major work expounding on Bismarck's pecuniary relationship with the prominent Prussian banker Gerson von Bleichroder, Gold and Iron is truly a seminal study about the rise of the German nation. It splendidly explores the creation of the Prusso-Germanic empire through the lens of Bismarck, its architect, and Bleichroder, his Jewish financier. Bleichroder became useful to Bismarck in many ways. He was embroiled in affaires d'Etat as well as Bismarck's affaires de famille. He managed the Chancellor's personal portfolio, helped finance wars against Denmark and Austria, and served as an intermediary for the massive indemnity levied against the French in the wake of the Franco-Prussian War. Bleichroder's remarkable and long-running relationship with the Rothschilds made his services doubly worthwhile to both Bismarck and Germany. However, Stern makes the poignant observation that while Bleichroder's success won him access to the corridors of power everywhere, his very success prevented him from being truly free. He became a kind of Tantalus, always seeking out recognition and confirmation of his accomplishments without really attaining what he was reaching for: a position at parity, if not becoming primus inter pares, vis-à-vis his peers and contemporaries. Ponderous the book may be, but readers who are deeply interested in the political economy of Europe and in the crucial role played by embattled financiers in the rise of empires will be exceedingly enlightened--and entertained--by this monumental tome.
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Au 196, Fe 56; Combined Atomic Weight 252,
By Giordano Bruno (Wherever I am, I am.) - See all my reviews (HALL OF FAME REVIEWER) (TOP 1000 REVIEWER)
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Gold and Iron (Paperback)
That's how heavy this 600 page history of the Prussian unification of Germany is! This study is so gravely massive, so chock-full of info and insights, that I'm sorely tempted to say: "Go ahead! Read it! I double-dare you!" It's taken me several months, with some prolonged stagnations in airport lounges, to finish it, and I'm not the slowest reader in juvenile hall. It's almost as indigestible as gold and a lot less malleable than iron. It's not at all badly written or poorly organized; it's just long, stolid, detailed, insistent, and dry. The writing reminds me a good deal of the American historian David Hackett Fischer; if either author were paid by the word, Bill Gates would need to borrow pocket money from them. Honestly, I had to treat each chapter as a separate volume, and give myself a concentration break between them.
If I haven't discouraged you from considering this book yet, let me say that it's also one of the most impressive feats of historiography that I've encountered in many years. It's well worth the work, assuming you have any interest in the history of Germany, or of European Jewry, or of political power in action. The "gold" in the title stands for the plutocratic banker Gerson Bleichröder, while the "iron" represents Bismark, the Iron Chancellor whose political and military tactics led to the unification of Germany in the last third of the 19th Century. Structurally, the book is a kind of parallel biography of the two men, who were indispensable to each other for most of their careers. Bismark's life and thought have been an entire industry for historians since his first political victories, but Bleichröder's role in Bismark's successes and rare failures has been neglected to the point of erasure. That historical amnesia was the starting point of Fritz Stern's investigations, when Stern became aware of the vast archive of the Banker's correspondence with the Chancellor and other personages of the era. It's a risky over-simplification of Stern's analysis to say that Bleichröder and his "gold" were necessary adjuncts to Bismark's accomplishments, but this book goes a long way to justify that hypothesis. Bleichröder was Bismark's personal financial manager, his "ear" to the world of finance both in Germany and elsewhere, his almost constant advisor and his favorite "behind-the-throne" manipulator, and perhaps as close to a 'friend' as the imperious Prince could have. Their 'atomic weights' as gold and iron are metaphorically inappropriate, in that Bismark's Iron always overbalanced and outweighed all the Gold of the richest financier in Germany. How politics and finance melded in the alloy of 19th C Germany is the chief subject of the book. Bismark's career began in a financially backward feudal society of land-proud Junkers, the most reactionary society of western/central Europe, and ended in the rapidly industrializing, militarily overbearing Germany that sought to rival England and overwhelm France in the race to colonialism that led to World War I. If any single individual of the 19th C "made history", it was Bismark. So at least all historians of Germany have maintained. But then, to what degree was Bleichröder (and by extension the whole world of finance) essential to that process of societal reconstruction? Stern offers very ample evidence that Bismark was more attentive to the raw power of money, both his own and the State's, than romantic German historians have supposed. Bleichröder was a very smart banker, a man who took care of his own interests with as much opportunistic ruthlessness as Bismark himself, but he was also an ambitious Jew, a parvenu in a society that didn't like parvenus and especially not Jewish ones. He was perceived by most people, including perhaps Bismark, as "Bismark's court Jew." Whether he perceived himself as such is another of Fritz Stern's topics of inquiry. The lifetimes of these two powerful men, Iron and Gold, was simultaneously the era during which European Jews achieved their most rapid progress toward civic and social rights, toward assimilation and/or equality, yet also the era during which anti-semitism flared and raged most furiously, stoking the fires for the Holocaust of the 20th C. As rapid and as impressive as the rise of Bleichröder and his peers must have seemed, the reaction of envy and hatred makes Bleichröder's life story a stunning tragedy. I need to confess that my knowledge of 19th C German history isn't vast. I have no means to challenge or criticize the contents of this book. I can only say that it convinces me by its sheer mass of data and by its thoroughness of analysis. Read also the earlier review by H. Schneider, a German by birth and language; it was he who alerted me to Stern, German-born but an immigrant to America in his youth.
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Elective Affinities,
By
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Gold and Iron (Paperback)
I have previously reviewed other books by Fritz Stern, an American historian of German-Jewish descent, born in a part of Germany that is now a part of Poland. He is one of the most interesting writers on German history of the 19th-20th centuries, and he has a lot to say on the history of German Jews and German anti-semitism.
His huge monography on Bismarck and his Jewish banker Bleichroeder is a masterpiece of historical jig saw puzzling, and it tells a fascinating story. We are looking at the high times of German imperial adolescence. Stern loves to play with the stylistic pattern of pairs: Blood and Iron (said Bismarck). Or Coal and Iron (said Keynes, later). Or Gold and Iron (says Stern, still later). More pairs: power & money, Junker & Jew, Bismarck & banker, old nobility & new presumptions, aristocrats & nouveaux riches. Gerson Bleichroeder was the first Prussian Jew who got ennobled without prior conversion. To his world of Prussian power, he was a convenience & an embarrassment. In the relation of the two men, Bismarck was dominant and Bleichroeder useful. There is no doubt whatsoever about the primacy of politics over economics. The banker thirsted for respectability & acceptance. He cherished secrecy, but sought recognition. His career embodied the ambivalence of Jewish success: needed, pampered, feted, maligned. Jews performed great economic feats, they were immeasurably useful and resented. Bleichroeder dropped out of German historiography like a stone in water, leaving mainly ephemeral ripples (until Stern went after him). Even Bismarck did not mention him in the first two volumes of his memoirs. Historians would give Bismarck plenty of shelf space (thousands of dedicated publications) and Bleichroeder none. Apotheosis & oblivion. This study was triggered by the appearance of a Bleichroeder letter archive in his former bank. Stern started his sleuthing work from there and then hit mother lodes in the archives of the Rothschilds and the Bismarcks. It is a remarkable job for its reconstruction of ignored informal structures in the politics of the time. It is a history of a social web. It is like a fat novel of the 19th century. (Do not think of Thomas Mann, more of his brother Heinrich, eg the Untertan, the Blue Angel.) It shows how the atmosphere of imperial Germany exuded sentimentalized self-righteousness, copious hypocrisy, distressing servility. It is a record of people sowing the wind, not knowing that later generations would reap the whirlwind. The book is essential for students of German history. I wish Stern had applied more economics in its writing: I bet one could cut a third of the hulk without major damage to the message. By the way, I remember that Harry Flashman had an encounter with Bismarck in one of the early Flashman volumes. Which one was that? (Flashman barely survived the meeting...)
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
|
|
See all 57 books this book cites
See all 100 books citing this book
Suggested Tags from Similar Products(What's this?)Be the first one to add a relevant tag (keyword that's strongly related to this product).
|
|
|
