From School Library Journal
PreSchool-Grade 2-In this warm story of intergenerational love, a girl re-creates a piece of her grandmother's childhood home in China. Nancy lives in a brownstone with her older brother, their parents, and Ni Ni, the youngsters' grandmother. The woman is sad to learn that her father's house in Suzhou, with its beautiful fishpond surrounded by chrysanthemums, is to be torn down for an apartment building. When Nancy wins two goldfish at a street fair, she decides to build a backyard fishpond. With the help of a kindly neighbor and her brother, she lays out a stone path, sets down an old picnic bench, plants flowers, and surprises Ni Ni. This portrait of a caring family resonates with scenes of sharing and togetherness. The rich golds, greens, and browns of the oil paintings add to the spirit of warmth and security. Use this book in multicultural and family story programs.
Susan Pine, New York Public LibraryCopyright 2003 Reed Business Information, Inc.
PreS-Gr. 2. Ni Ni, Nancy's grandmother, gets a letter from China telling her that her ancestral home is being razed for apartment buildings. As Ni Ni recalls with melancholy the lovely goldfish pond surrounded by yellow mums, Nancy decides she must do something to raise Ni Ni's spirits. First, Nancy wins a pair of goldfish at a fair. When that doesn't seem enough, Nancy, with help from her neighbor and brother, builds a small pond for the goldfish in the backyard and surrounds it with chrysanthemums. The telling is direct, and the message about bringing happiness to those one loves is clear. Cheng's artwork conveys both the action and the deep familial love without ambiguity, but the decision to give the artwork a golden patina produces a similitude that borders on tedium. Best for larger libraries or ones with immigrant populations that can really appreciate ties to a faraway place.
Ilene CooperCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved