Customer Reviews

Good Cook 24 Count Cupcake Pan and Carrying Case

5 star:		(10)
4 star:		(4)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(4)

 

 

I used this carrier to take some cupcakes to a birthday party that my friend was giving for her daughter. I placed the carriers in the trunk of a car and we traveled from Brooklyn to Manhattan and back. I was pleased to see that the cakes didn't just survive the trip, but they looked the same as when I packed them. The top part of the carrier was great, but the metal bottom part gave me some trouble getting the cupcakes out. The carrier was easy to transport, and can take a few bumps without messing the contents up.
Unfortunately, the second day I had them, the latch on one of them broke off, however I was able to reattatch it easily. Also, when placing the top level over the bottom, you do run the risk of smudging the sides of the bottom layer because they have to align perfectly, and you might not notice the alignment is off until you try to close it.
I am still happy with my purchase.

I have had this product for over a year. It has been utilized many times to take cupcakes to school and to parties. I don't bake in the bottom pan, though it can be used for that. Only two complaints, that I can easily live with:

1.) The top plastic holder does tend to be flimsy in the middle, but it has not presented an issue for me. (Some people have complained about removing the cupcakes from the bottom pan, but I just use a spoon and easily lift them out).

2.) It is wonderful to carry 24 cupcakes in, however if you are a "pretty frosting" baker, the levels may not be tall enough to carry the cupcakes without flattening the frosting. For this, I often don't frost the cupcakes until I have arrived at the final destination.

Overall, I recommend this product, it has been a great convenience for me... and my kids can handle carrying it by themselves.

I am a target shopper. I also make alot of cupcakes for my children's school parties. So I bought two. I was very disappointed. There is not alot of room for frosting on the bottom layer of cupcakes. Plus the red divider that holds the top cupcakes bows under the weight when it is filled with the cupcakes. Hence, smashed frosting on the bottom cupcakes. I expected better quality from Target. This is definently a Walmart product. I should have looked a little closer to the Oneida carrier.

I used this once and it did work well for transporting the cupcakes; however, the latch broke on mine the second time I used it. It was easy to fix that, but then the plastic also broke around the latch. I returned it.

I have started making a lot of cupcakes for functions. So much so, that I am now referred to as "the cupcake girl."

I bought one cupcake carrier from another company even after a friend tried to convince me not to because Ross on occasion has this particular carrier for cheaper. Well, I bought the other one thinking I'd return it if I indeed found a cheaper alternative.

Well, about a month later sure enough, she found me one and bought it. I used it for the first time this week. I hate this thing!

The red top carrier bows under the weight of the cupcakes, doesn't sit securely on the bottom, and I can't stand the bottom.

Another reviewer said getting cupcakes out of the bottom gave her a little trouble. I'm gonna be real, I could not get the things out of there without sticking my fingers all in the frosting. I gave it two stars because it does keep them safe while traveling, I have to give them that. But I hate this thing. Look elsewhere.

This carrier is useless! The bottom layer of cupcakes is difficult to remove without smudging the frosting, since holes used for baking are much deeper than the holes should be in a cupcake carrier, plus the bottom layer also frequently gets ruined by the top layer. Spend the money on a different carrier and a separate baking pan. MUCH worth your while.

For the most part this carrier is fine. The only drawbacks I've found with it are that the decorated cupcakes can be somewhat tricky to get out without damaging them or getting frosting all over your fingers (or the tray itself). The additional plastic tray is not very sturdy and noticeably sags in the middle under the weight of the cupcakes, which makes it kind of useless unless you are transporting cupcakes that aren't frosted.

It's nice to use without the plastic tray if you do a lot of fancy decorating because the cover leaves a lot of room for the taller cupcakes. However, I personally prefer Wilton Ultimate 3-In-1 Cupcake Caddy and Carrier because its sides are not tapered and thus you don't end up possibly smooshing the sides of the cupcake's frosting. (At the time of this writing, it's actually cheaper than this carrier, too.)

But, in the end, it's definitely better than nothing.

What a great product! Locks securely for carrying, love the way it stores by flipping the middle layer over and becoming more compact. It only fits the small cupcakes though. Highly recommend this product.

I purchased this item for a friend and have not used it myself, but it seems to be well made and the recipient was well pleased.Good Cook 24 Count Cupcake Pan and Carrying Case

My daughter bought this for me and it is perfect for traveling with cupcakes. They stay secure and are not damaged in transit. You can carry two dozen cupcakes and one of the layers is a cupcake pan so it does double duty. My niece who really loves to make cupcakes liked mine so much I bought one for her.