Most Helpful Customer Reviews
37 of 41 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Disappointing, March 3, 2005
This review is from: A Good Hard Kick in the Ass: Basic Training for Entrepreneurs (Hardcover)
Like other reviewers have noted, this book is aimed at a very particular audience: successful executives with significant experience, starting a technology company.
I figured I was close enough to that audience that I'd love the book. Turns out, I was wrong. This book is overwhelmingly focused on enterprise companies. I am the CEO of a consumer-focused company, and felt like the book was misleadingly positioned. Maybe "Basic Training for Entrepreneurs selling into the Enterprise" wouldn't have been as catchy... but it would be much more accurate.
I also found Rob's book troubling for softer reasons. For me, probably the most important decision I ever made was my choice of co-founders. Absolutely, you want a smart team just like Rob recommends... but you also want a team of people you can *trust* with your life. I was surprised by Rob's total focus on hard skills/experience in hiring.
But upon reflection, his focus on hard skills makes sense here, since the book is overwhelmingly about making money. If you want to build a team of people who want to change the world... or make a difference... this book is not for you. I'm not talking about non-profits or government; I'm talking about creating products that have an impact on the world (Apple, Sony, Google, Harley, Ben & Jerry's, Intuit, etc.).
This book has zero talk about creating a shared sense of purpose/mission. That's ok, because companies targeting the enterprise rarely have that sort of vibe. That's too bad, because I think that every company can use a "soul". And to be frank, creating a sense of purpose/mission can dramatically increase customer and employee retention. Maybe all this soft stuff can translate into hard dollars after all...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great on validating the market in early stage start-ups, May 8, 2005
This review is from: A Good Hard Kick in the Ass: Basic Training for Entrepreneurs (Hardcover)
This excellent book describes the early start up stage of a new business in great detail. The author has experience with pre-funded start-ups and their efforts to validate their markets. There are few books that describe this early stage activity for entrepreneurs, where it's difficult to judge a market. Thus, this book is highly recommended.
Pluses
- Puts proper weights on crucial start up tasks with an emphasis on the execution team. The author says execution and the execution team is more important than the idea. He makes a good point but I don't think having a good execution team is adequate reason to create a startup. You still need an organizing idea that offers overwhelming advantage.
- Recommends that you apply new technology to existing market to ease an existing pain. He particularly likes applying new technologies to business processes (of course Dell is one of the examples here).
- Asks you to repeatedly hypothesize and then prove/disprove the pain of your prospects. The area of customer need has to have a felt pain. The search for pain increases the likelihood of success, and makes marketing easier.
- Recommends rigorous upfront market research into prospects and influencers. Talk to at least 100 potential customers. After doing this the author says the business plan is easier to write.
- I liked his comments on talking to affinity groups, trade pubs, user groups, trade shows, and industry influencers.
- Get to the market quickly with a product that solves their immediate pain.
Minuses
- Relies on quantitative market research for initial phase instead of one-on-one. His defense is that our goal is to be doing market research, not selling our solution. However, I believe the best market research comes from one on one discussions. See Barry Feig's books on market research for more on this, "Marketing Straight To the Heart" etc..
Questionable Items
- Your idea does not have to be unique. "There is no new idea." To the author, ideas are commodities, it's teams that can execute that are scarce. While I agree, I can't see starting up a company unless you have a competitive advantage that goes beyond our subjective opinion of a start-up crew.
- First to market is no big thing, it's an unsustainable advantage. Execute to dominate, not define a space. I generally disagree, but he makes a good point. I also believe in first mover advantage made popular by Geoffrey Moore ("Crossing the Chasm") and also in Ries's recommendation to create a new niche to dominate (See "The Origin of Brands" by Al and Laura Ries). But I also believe, like the author suggests, great execution is often a deciding factor. I think he gives these other ideas short shrift because he sees so many companies failing on execution.
- Partner, partner, partner. I think the startup should try for a complete product rather than give up large pieces of the solution. But I can see how some situations demand this.
There's a lot more to this book than the few points I listed above. He gives more details on the execution team which were particularly good.
Overall, I think this is an excellent book. It should be required reading for all MBA students of entrepreneurial studies as well as anyone in the early stages of a startup who is trying to validate the company's market.
John Dunbar
Sugar Land, TX
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Good Hard Knock on the Head, August 14, 2002
This review is from: A Good Hard Kick in the Ass: Basic Training for Entrepreneurs (Hardcover)
After starting a couple of businesses, and running into every kind of possible start-up problem. I'm always looking for good practical advice from others who've worked with start-ups to help me avoid making dumb mistakes and wasting precious time. I picked up Rob Adam's book because after reading a few pages at the bookstore, and it became obvious this was not one of those typical "succeed by connecting the right dots" method books for arm chair techno-startup wannabes. There was a lot of straightforward wisdom in his pages which I hope to draw on when I get stuck in a crisis situation (which is usually every day). Several things stand out in this book: 1) Validate your market. Very true, common sense advice. He gives a clear guideline for how his company structures this process. Might not work for everyone scrambling to survive, but the point is still there. Do the homework first. 2) Defines what is good money vs bad money. 3) Ideas are easy. It's the execution that counts. 4) People invest in people, not plans. Some things that didn't really help: 1) Most of us are not connected enough to sip beers with big VC investors on a patio. (If a VC is reading, email me, and I'll fly over from Taiwan immediately to do some sipping with you!) 2) The kind of money that's being talked about is not readily available to most people these days. 3) The straight forward partnering concept that is so prevalent in the US, doesn't often work in other parts of the world. Conclusion: Well worth taking the time to read, think about, evaluate, and put into action. Can really help you if you are wandering off course in "business plan land¡¨.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|