4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Blast from the past, July 8, 2009
This review is from: The Good Soldier Schweik (DVD)
"The Good Soldier Schweik" 1956 (color) film is based on the legendary novel by Czech writer Jaroslav Hasek. The book itself, illustrated by Josefa Lady is a one of a kind treasure, and Schweik has achieved a folk hero status. The film is a comedy-satire about the trials and tribulations of a simple, officially declared to be "dim-witted" soldier Schweik during the First World War. Schweik's business as a civilian is selling dogs, some many times over. That part is not fully covered in the film. In the book his business methods makes you roll with laughter.
Schweik's political views and actions are not exactly anti-establishment, although the establishment does not believe him.
After the assassination of Ferdinand in Sarajevo, Schweik openly predicts the declaration of war, for which he is arrested. Subsequently, even though he supports The War, he is placed in a mental institution for people with ailments trying to avoid being sent to the front. There, the treatment for all ailments is daily pumping of the stomach and enemas, until the patient gets cured by volunteering for the front.
At a sermon for the prisoners by a drunk Chaplain, Schweik begins to sob. After the sermon the Chaplain asks him why he was sobbing, to which Schweik replies that he wanted to show to all that the Chaplain had succeeded in reforning a sinner. That changes Schweik's luck and he becomes the Chaplain's orderly. Later the Chaplain loses him in a card game and Schweik becomes the orderly of another officer. As an orderly Schweik always manages to satisfy the wishes of his bosses, many times by hilarious means and with unintended consequences.
The casting and the performances are very good. As a bonus, the action takes place in Prague and the viewer get a mini tour of one of the World's most beautiful, ancient cities.
There are two reasons why I did not give the film 5 stars. The first is that unless you know the Czech language, you will be reading the sub-titles and you will be missing some of the richness and humor of the film. Further, the sub-titles stay on the screen a short time. You have to be a fast reader to read them all without pausing. The second is that the film ends when Schweik is sent to the front. You have to get Schweik 2 DVD to get the full story.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
This is the Czech film of 1957-58, not the German one with Senta Berger, etc., January 27, 2011
This review is from: The Good Soldier Schweik (DVD)
Axel von Ambesser directed Heinz Rühmann in the 1960 German film, but this isn't it.
I have only seen the Czech film, which has the DVD cover shown here. It is not well transferred to DVD, and needs color correction. If you want to see Schweik headed for the front, you need the second film, "Beg to Report, Sir." This film offers some chuckles and nice views of Prague, where it all takes place, but the original novel remains a better way to experience Schweik.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
