Most Helpful Customer Reviews
21 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Progressive Rock Masterpiece, June 8, 2003
Procol Harum's Grand Hotel- recorded in 1973 - is a masterpiece of progressive rock. You all know about the other classic from the same year- Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon ( for this reviewer, ELP's Brain Salad surgery also qualifies). Like Dark Side of the Moon, Procol's Grand Hotel album has excellent production and sound quality. It also represents a step further for this band on every level- as noted by another reviewer- this is where it all came together for them. Aided by Producer Chris Thomas and the use of strings and a chorus, Procol creates a luxurious wall of sound for many of the songs on Grand Hotel. The superb production, musicianship and compositions represent the zenith of Procol Harum's achievement... nothing they did before or since was as good. Other than Broken Barricades, many of the Earlier Procol albums were pretty lightweight and patchy compared to Grand Hotel...they just don't have the power and sonic sophistication that this recording does. I agree with the people who feel that this was the classic line up of the band (though I'm sure there are plenty of Matthew Fisher proponents)- Mick Grabham proved to be a much better guitarist for Procol Harum, his sound and style being more compatible than Trower. Grand Hotel's title track alone makes it worth owning, but there are plenty of other nuggets to be found here...it is consistently good almost throughout. Even TV Ceaser is a musically great song, once you acclimate yourself to its lyrics..other than the title track, "Bringing home the bacon" is the showstopper of the album, featuring some of the best drumming and guitar work of any Procol song. "For Liquorice John" and "Fires which burnt brightly" marry lyrics with music perfectly- they also provide the albums most emotional songs. I really like the Chris Thomas produced period of Procol Harum, and this one is the best of the lot (Exotic Bird's and Fruit is also excellent). Anyone seeking a slightly different flavor of progressive rock would do well to start with Grand Hotel...an album which manages to be both sophisticated AND heavy. It also deserves mention that Repertoire Records did an outstanding job with both the audio remastering and graphic artwork for this reissue...pick it up and discover a diamond in the rough.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Grand In Every Way..., February 4, 2010
Following the huge success of their prior LP, 'LIVE WITH THE EDMONTON SYMPHONY ORCHESTRA', # 5 on the Billboard Album charts, Procol continued similiarly w/ use of orchestrations on this, their 6th release, with spellbinding results. Every track is a jewel, every word is a gem, and this one has always been one of my favorite Harum LP`s even after all these years. It`s grand on every level, magnificent perhaps, and caters to their strengths like no other. The album cover and title track remind me of the Greta Garbo movie of the same name that came out in the mid 1930`s - it reeks of a lush, languid, elegant decadence and despair, as does the film. Brooker wrote some of his most memorable melodies for this LP, and Keith Reid penned indelible lyrics to further burn the tunes to permanent memory ('Grand Hotel' and 'Fires Which Burnt Brightly' in particular). The vastly underrated B.J. Wilson (RIP) provides some of his most superlative, muscular drumming - why more people don`t acknowledge his skills as a drummer has always irked me to no end - listen to the incredible foundation he provides on 'Bringing Home The Bacon' and the powerful accents he uses to diffuse and dissect the orchestrations on the title track as proof. Unfortunately, when this LP came out in 1973, Glam-rock was all the rage, so this one slipped between the cracks for many listeners, though it did go to #21 on Billboard, but was never going to stand toe-to-toe w/ the likes of Ziggy Stardust or 'Dark Side' or Roxy Music (another fave of mine). If hindsight teaches us anything, this Lp deserves a re-examination like few others do.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Top Classic Rock Album - 30 later years - still the best, December 18, 2005
One of the greatest adult classic rock albums of all times! The album is like a tour of a Grand Hotel where every room contains a demonstration of a human depravity - over-eating, drinking, obsessive love, mindless TV, drug addiction, suicide, sex and war. Classy, forbodding, sad, angry, funny and purposefully campy.
Fantasitc lyrics, music and musicianship. A wild and crazy use of orchestras, choirs, pianos, electric guitars, organs and drumming. Along with the lyrics (real poetry!)- its a roller coaster ride. The experience is greatest when the album is played loud!
The record sounds fantastic. There is almost no hiss and the base sounds great. Crystal clear sound! Brookers piano can be heard clearly and his voice is one of the best in any music anywhere.
Requires only a little patience, but numerous listenings. Analyzing the Keith Reid metaphors in the poetry is challenging but fun and his bidding you enter the hotel on the inside cover is classic. Grand Hotel is an absolute must for mature thinking people who want more then the usual dribble in their rock.
Friday Music's booklet has all the lyrics. The CD includes the wonderful addition of a live version of Grand Hotel with lots of Garry's piano and his diversion into Over The Rainbow!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|