As much as comics deal with religion, analysis
of religion in comics is sadly lacking. [...] Happily, Graven Images
is the first step in filling that gap in scholarship.
--Rebecca Buchanan, Sequential Tart (December 2010)
In the mind of the present reviewer, there was not a single weak piece in this collection, and all were enjoyable and insightful, and well worth reading. --Phillip A. Bernhardt-House, Eternal Haunted Summer (Winter 2010)
Unlike so many studies of, say, "religion and film" that continue to treat the audio-visual medium as if it were a type of literature, the contributors here take the comics medium seriously, juxtaposing analyses of words, frames, pages, and images, and pointing toward comics as a whole. [...] Graven Images
establishes comics as a vital subject matter, and provides an array of strong essays that display various ways the comic-religion relation can be seen.
--S. Brent Plate, Relegere: Studies in Religion and Reception
"Every art form has told stories of faith, and sequential art embodiments have included Egyptian tomb paintings, the traditional Stations of the Cross, and Bible comics from the last century. With the recent graphic novel boom, religious themes and interpretations abound, mostly summarized in a dozen or so popular books like Stephen Skelton's The Gospel According to Super­heroes
, Arie Kaplan's From Krakow to Krypton: Jews and Comic Books
, and Jeff Dunn and Adam Palmer's The Soul of Spider-Man: Unexpected Spiritual Insights from the Legendary Superhero
. Graven Images
appears to be the first to take a broader and more academic approach, collecting 21 essays from a conference of the same name held at Boston University. While most of the contributors have faculty appointments, five are comics creators. Themes range across religions and denominations, from expected topics (animistic and Christian themes in the manga/anime Nausicaä) to surprising ones (connections between religion and underground comics). VERDICT This varied and thoughtful collection invites more serious consideration of the medium thematically and hopefully presages additional conferences and collections. For all academic and larger public libraries." — Library Journal
"Graven Images excels at offering sophisticated interpretations of comic books and graphic novels that demand critical attention...Undoubtedly, Graven Images is a valuable contribution to the study of religion and popular culture. For religion scholars engaged in comic book/graphic novel criticism, the collection sets a high mark and will likely become an essential reference point for those in the field. For general scholars of religion or popular culture, Graven Images offers insight into how religion is a self-conscious engagement for comic book authors and readers, yielding works of depth and power within genres frequently dismissed as child's play." —The Journal of Popular Culture