Most Helpful Customer Reviews
30 of 32 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
A solid ripoff, June 9, 2002
This review is from: Graveyards of the Pacific: From Pearl Harbor to Bikini Island (Hardcover)
This book purports to take the reader "on a tour" of Pacific warship shipwrecks. What a complete crock. There are probably not a dozen wrecks covered here; all the photos save one are very small and mostly boring (unless you're really keen to see portholes underwater). Two photos come from the Japanese merchant wrecks at Truk, some of the most-photographed wrecks in the world (and offered in exceptionally better quality in other publications). The only large wreck illustration is a lovely Tom Freeman painting of the YORKTOWN wreck. Nice, but by no means worth the space on your bookshelf. If you're someone who knows nothing about the Pacific war, then this is a reasonably good primer of some of the major actions. If you already know what the Battle of Midway was and have some idea that the Americans and Japanese each had aircraft carriers, this book will tell you nothing about the war you don't already know, and the photos, while nice, are available in dozens of other books. If you're looking for some interesting views of the shipwrecks Ballard has made his reputation on finding, you will find nothing of interest here. Save your money, and pass this one up.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
20 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Not up to the usual standards, June 26, 2001
This review is from: Graveyards of the Pacific: From Pearl Harbor to Bikini Island (Hardcover)
Having purchased everything ever published by Dr. Ballard, I eagerly awatied this release. Upon first glance, the book appears to be every inch what his previous volumes have been, with the exception of the mediocre "Explorations". After reading this though, I can't call it more than a short compilation of his previous works on Midway and Gudalcanal, with short side trips to Pearl Harbor, Truk, and Bikini. There are very few photogrpahs of wrecks, certainly not anywhere near the amount in previous volumes...AND WHERE ARE KEN MARSCHALL's PAINTINGS? Overall, I felt rather underwhelmed. Bikini has been done better in "Ghost Fleet", and the Submeged Cultural Resource unit did a bettr job at Pearl Harbor. On the up side, there is one haunting internal photograph from the Arizona...hardly enough to recommend full retail for this book. Wait for it to be $4.99 in a few weeks if you simply must have it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
18 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Not like I thought..., March 10, 2002
This review is from: Graveyards of the Pacific: From Pearl Harbor to Bikini Island (Hardcover)
When I recieved a letter from a seller of this book asking for an order for it I thought: "Wow, shipwrecks... especially ones from WWII!" As a student in an oceanography-themed high school, I was right away interested in this book. The excerpts and details from the preview made it sound great. However when the book came in, it wasn't what I thought. The book was nicely writen by Dr. Ballard, but the detail of each section was nothing to brag about. The book shows each area as a section. Beginning with Pearl Harbor, each section describes a certain battle scene involving the Navy. From Midway to Guadalcanal, each battle is shown with photos and diagrams. However these pictures and maps are not really enough to satisfy your thirst for WWII information. The text ends off in a way and talks about something else, and the lack of good photos make each section seem empty. When I opened to the Midway chapter I expected more in-depth information on the battle. Instead I got a lot less than the National Geographic article on Midway from '99. None of the planes were mentiond much, and when they mentioned a PBY, they did not show what this scout plane looked like, making you have to use your imagination to picture the Catalina plane. This book is supposed to mention salvage oeprations for the wrecks and exploration expeditions to them as well. However most of the text is a history lesson rather than a step in Marine Affairs. Out of the entire book I would say about 20% is actual expedition info. As an owner of many of Dr. Ballards works, I would have to say this one is not one of his best.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|