4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Two great classics in one handsome Nonesuch Edition, May 7, 2009
This review is from: Great Expectations and Hard Times (Nonesuch Dickens) (Hardcover)
My review here is not of the novel, but rather of the Nonesuch edition of Dickens' classic. The book itself is a facsimile edition of the 1937 Nonesuch Dickens, and is published by Barnes and Noble. The book itself is in quality hardback. The "Great Expectations and Hard Times" Nonesuch edition has the spine bound in leather and the rest of the cover is cloth-bound [the color is blue-grey].The dust jacket is clear quality plastic. The paper quality is of good stock and is cream in color.
The text is set in Martin's Type and the illustrations are from the original Nonesuch editions [8 illustrations in "Great Expectations", and 5 illustrations in "Hard Times"]. This is a beautiful and affordable classic and the Nonesuch Dickens Classics will enhance any collector's library.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Copy of the Famous Nonesuch Edtion, February 7, 2009
These commonly available replications of printer Frances Meynell's famous 1937 Nonesuch printing of Dickens Works should not be taken too seriously. While nicely done they are light years away from the de luxe originals. Those were printed on specially selected handmade paper, paper that managed the pretty - and quite expensive - feat of being both thin and solidly opague. Quality was the watchword throughout, and having seen a complete set years ago, I certainly would never in a million mistake one of these volumes for the 1937 edition. Taken from the 1867 Chapman and Hall edition, the last edition Dickens proofed, the 1937 Nonesuch edition of 24 volumes was as you might expect extremely expensive and very limited, selling during the depths of the Depression for fifty-six guineas, conservatively updated to be roughly $5,000 dollars in todays money. (Actually, they would sell for much, much more!)
So what then is the series listed here? Basically it's a large print hardback edition of Dickens - though currently only six volumes seem to exist. The quality is above average, with cloth boards and a spine that might - MIGHT - be leather. The books have weight - always a nice sign - and certainly are a considerable cut above the usual hardbound editions of classics proliferating bookstore shelves! Each comes with a glassine cover and a partial paper wrapper describing the Nonesuch edition. The sewn pages lie flat nicely enough - a distinct plus, and the text is not too badly printed, though by no means comes a country mile to the crisp printing of the original editions. Inside the books - I have two, this one and Bleak House - the illustrations chosen by Dickens are well done.
This is presented as a facsimile edition, but there are facsimiles and there are facsimiles. This makes a generous stab at offering a most affordable version of a printing legend, but to be honest it's not quite what it claims.
It is important, too, to note that two editions of this facsimile series seem to exist. The covers of mine are different, with an embossed image of the Nonesuch bear on a cheap Thailand Barnes and Noble edition printed by arrangement with Overlook Press, dated 2005. (The example above.) There is now a later Overlook edition from 2008. I cannot say whether it's more refined and better made than this earlier Barnes and Noble, which, by the way, did not sell well, as my copy of "Great Expectations/Hard Times" was discounted down to $6.99.
Hopefully someone will offer some additonal insights on these two versions so Amazon readers can better chose.
As it stands, these are nice hardbound versions, though they do suffer from pages that are not opague enough to hide the printing of the second side.
Happy Birthday - Charles Dickens!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No