From School Library Journal
Kindergarten-Grade 3-Hickcox chronicles the life of a woman by offering glimpses of her as a child, young wife, mother, and grandmother. As a great-grandmother, she marvels that "...inside I am still exactly me." Through the years, she tells her husband and offspring that some day the numerous pockets on a raggedy apron she has made will be filled with treasures. At her death, no one can see what has stuffed the seemingly empty pockets because the treasures are "the things she had given away" such as cookies, smiles, stories, and games. Soman's illustrations are more successful in depicting static scenes than in capturing movement. Great-grandfather's facial structure evolves more believably through the aging process than does his wife's. Hickcox's intent to demonstrate to children that their elders were once young is admirable in theory but problematic in execution. Besides the difficulty in incorporating abstract concepts noted above, some of the repeated phrases add a stilted quality to the text. This is a very sentimental journey.
Kathy Piehl, Mankato State University, MNCopyright 1999 Reed Business Information, Inc.
This sentimental story of a woman's life begins with her birth and ends with her death. In between, the reader discovers a caring, giving person who delights in making other people happy. As a young bride, she sews an apron with many pockets that someday she will fill with "special treasure." Her apron becomes famous among her children, grandchildren, and great-grandchildren for always having empty pockets. But that's not the truth. All those pockets are filled with the gifts she gave away--smiles, cookies, "ghost stories and Mud Puddle Soup." Soman's paintings, done in watercolor and pastels, have a nostalgic quality that matches the text. This may have more appeal for adults than children. However, at the right time, this picture book for older readers may help children get a new perspective on the adults in their lives and how those adults always carry their own inner child.
Kathy Broderick