From School Library Journal
Gr 7 Up-This exhaustively researched book explores the similarities and differences among the tales told by various Native American cultural groups about the creation of the world, life, and death. Following an introductory chapter that describes the importance of lore and myths to our understanding of a cultural group, the text is organized by region. Within each area, the relationships among the tales of specific groups are discussed as well as the basic themes present in the stories of other peoples outside this area. Surprisingly, considering Philip's other work, the dry text reads more like a research report than an engaging narrative. Some of the retellings incorporated into it as illustrative examples reflect the work of an excellent storyteller while others lack this spark. Numerous sepia-toned archival photographs that loosely relate to the material discussed are found throughout the book. Their substantial captions contain a great deal of additional, explanatory material along with information on the source of the photograph, photographer, and date. The extensive bibliography is organized by geographical area. While not a title for students interested in leisure reading, it is a worthy book that will support research on Native American folklore.
Linda Greengrass, Bank Street College Library, New York City
Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
Gr. 8-12. Philip, who wrote
A Braid of Lives: Native American Childhood (2000), here examines the themes and stories in Native American mythology. The book is divided into eight chapters, each examining the common themes and stories told by tribes in a single region. Because of this structure, there is not always uniform coverage of topics among regions. Each section contains stories of creation, but then topics diverge to relate trickster tales, stories of the buffalo hunt, the ritual of pipe smoking, and other tales that provide the spiritual foundation for the activities of daily life. The rather complex lacework of stories and their variants, coupled with the names of numerous gods and mortals mentioned in the text, makes this best suited for sophisticated readers who have some familiarity with the myths but want a bigger picture of Native American spirituality. Well-captioned photographs by Edward S. Curtis and other late-nineteenth- and early-twentieth-century photographers illustrate the text, which includes both an index and a lengthy bibliography.
Randy MeyerCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved