3.0 out of 5 stars
It made me stop liking Keats, January 27, 2012
This review is from: The Great Poets John Keats (Audio CD)
I discovered Keats and have loved him since about the age of 20. I'd only heard him read once before. After much begging, a friend I made in London read "Welcome Joy & Welcome Sorrow". This was years ago.
I never realized it from reading them alone, but these poem are pompous, shallow, grandiose, paradoxically usually very thin, ridiculous, not at all musical (despite Scott Fitzgerald's tears!) - they're terrible! Blackwood's and The Quarterly weren't nice, but they were right!
But. About this CD (which I snatched up when I found it). Keats according to a friend of his read his poems with a heavy sing-song accent. These readers don't go that far (though I wouldn't have objected it they had), but (thank god! unlike some hideous readings of poems I've heard) there is a clear feel for the meter in them. And I would say they are well-read, clearly enunciated, easily understood and read of course by Englishmen. If you like Keats, I see no reason why you wouldn't enjoy them. Unless, like me, your love (illusion) is completely shattered and you are disenchanted.
Three final notes. "La Belle Dame". If you can't tell from the title (I can never keep them straight), the version read is "knight at arms". I prefer (and thought I loved) "wretched wight". I believe the "wight" version is Keats' revision and evidently the one he preferred. Okay. Find it in an anthology! Great critics of poetry and Keats (who couldn't write a line of poetry if they tried!) know better than Keats what's good in Keats, and "knight at arms" is the one almost always anthologized. Modern Library prints "wight" and Random House's collection of poems and letters prints both. The English Oxford "complete" Keats prints "knight".
"The Eve Of St. Agnes". It is done like a play. Different readers take different characters/voices in the poem. The meter is shot. Because it is in fact not a play, it's a poem.
Finally, when I put this CD on, the first few poems swept over me like a wonderful, beautiful wave. The water receded.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No