7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
visually stunning representations that adults will appreciate probably even more than kids., December 22, 2010
This review is from: The Great Treasury of Christmas Comic Book Stories (Hardcover)
You'd have to be a true grinch to dislike this collection of great, classic comic book stories about Christmas. Editor Craig Yoe has assembled a very nice assortment of favorites from comics' Golden Age, the majority of which come from the John Stanley, Walt Kelly, and Richard Scarry. Other creators appearing in these pages include Dan Noonan, Frank Johnson, Klaus Nordling, Al Fago, Dan Gormley, Mike Sekowsky, and the wonderful Alberto Giolitti, whose artwork on "The Christmas Story" is truly brilliant.
The 21 stories here run from simple delightfully simple ("A Mouse in the House," "Ticky Tack, the Littlest Reindeer") to nostalgic looks at a long-ago time ("A Letter for Santa," "Joe and Jennifer in The Wonderful Snowhouse") to much beloved classics ("The Night Before Christmas," "A Christmas Carol"). It's with the classics that the artists really show off their skills, creating visually stunning representations that adults will appreciate probably even more than kids.
The rest of the stories are, as one would expect, cheerful examples of the spirit of Christmas. This book would make a wonderful addition to many children's libraries.
All that's really missing, from an adult perspective, is text that would frame each of the stories properly. Each story is presented with no context, no description, no background. Kids won't miss that, but adults like me would love to know more about the creators, the stories, and where they came from. The reader has to check the copyright page to find out what year each story was published--it would be nice if that information had also been put on the table of contents for easier reference. Nevertheless, The Great Treasury of Christmas Comic Book Stories is a joy-filled experience for the season.
-- John Hogan
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Hey, kids, Christmas comics!, December 10, 2011
This review is from: The Great Treasury of Christmas Comic Book Stories (Hardcover)
This hardcover book reprints Christmas comic book stories from 1945 to 1961. Most stories are taken from Santa Claus Funnies, which was published once a year by Dell Comics from 1942 to 1961. There are multiple stories by the brilliant John Stanley and Walt Kelly, with individual stories by many other creators. These are all great, heartwarming stories. Some comic book characters like Archie Andrews and Little Lulu were known for having annual Christmas comic books; you won't find any of those stories here. The only comic book characters with their own series to be featured here are Atomic Mouse and the obscure Li'l Tomboy. It's a shame that DC Comics' Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer comics aren't included, but you can't have everything. Maybe DC will publish their own Rudolph Archives someday, but who knows if they even have the rights to the character anymore?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No