Customer Reviews

The Greedy Hand: How Taxes Drive Americans Crazy and What to Do About It

5 star:		(19)
4 star:		(7)
3 star:		(3)
2 star:		(7)
1 star:		(10)

 

 

This should be required Civics reading for high school students. The author gives a politically non-biased explanation of the events that have warped simple tax proposals into Frankenstein's monster.

This book is similar To Martin Gross's the Tax Racket. It provides good summaries of the various taxes that we are slammed with by all levels of government. However, the portion of the subtitle telling us what we can do about the problem is short and weak. Elect politicians who will cut our taxes...yeah, ok. The only way the American people will get rid of the IRS and the income tax is if we all collectively decide to not file returns next year and we amend our W-4's so that no witholding tax is taken out. Hell, they can't arrest all of us. Where is the Spirit of 76?

Most Americans believe that their government is greedy. Those who do will still find this book earth shatering. Shlaes gives stunning examples of just how much Americans are being ripped off by the current tax code. In painstaking detail she describes how achievement, hard work, and even marriage are punished by the greed of the U.S. government. She points out very effectively that it is now possible to make too much money. When one reads this, one can't help but think that the government views them only as a revenue target. Her chapter on the I.R.S. is very enlightening. It is commonly believed that the I.R.S. is tyrannical. One would think that if it was tyrannical it would at least be effective. Shlaes really hits one out in describing just how ineffective the I.R.S. is. Also, Shlaes argues very convincingly that problems such as rising healthcare costs and the collapse of public education can, at the heart of the matter, be blamed on an inefficient tax code. Words cannot effectively state just how powerful this book is. A must read for all Americans. Maybe then some real tax reform will begin.

The 20th century was an arms race between the governments in the United States and its citizens to determine who would control the citizens' income. Government was on the offense and the citizens were on the defense. The citizens lost to date. Taxes went from less than 5 percent of income to 40 percent over that time. Most would agree that we cannot afford another century like that one.

This book nicely lays out the history of taxes that take more income and waste a lot of time and effort in the process. The author looks at sales taxes, withholding taxes at work, the marriage penalty in the income tax, whether the housing deduction for interest and taxes is a good thing or not, the problems with taxes on domestic help, property taxes and school support, the social security system, and estate taxes.

She doesn't like much of what she sees, and is concerned that reform could simply lead to adding new types of taxes (like a national sales tax while keeping all of the old taxes).

The newer the tax or tax idea, it seems like the worse it is working.

Her solutions are basically principles to be followed in reforming taxes. I doubt if they will be followed anytime soon. Recent polls show that most Americans are concerned about paying off the national debt and fixing social security before doing anything about cutting taxes.

Although most of her observations were good ones, I was a little doubtful about her automatic focus on the high income people being taken to the cleaners unfairly. There was not as much attention paid to benefits that lower income people may be receiving.

If you spend time thinking about how to keep your tax bill down, there's not much new in this book. If you are new to all of the ways that government helps you spend your money, this is a good introduction to the subject.

The book is well written and pleasant to read. The only drawback I found was that it was a little depressing to be reminded of how much I actually pay to all of the various governments.

Although many Americans are aware that our tax rates are high and getting higher, the "Greedy Hand", shows us just how and how much the government steals from its citizens. It is very clear that although we have a representative republic and a capitalist economy, we are behaving more and more like any socialist country in Europe. We have cast the federal government as a twisted version of Robin Hood, stealing from the "rich" and giving to the "poor". The means through which this occurs runs the gamut from payroll taxes to the bewildering concept of the progressive tax, which punishes persons who dare to make a success of themselves. I am perplexed by the 15% flat tax opponents who cry that the rich won't pay their "fair share" - although these folks shoulder over 90% of the nation's tax burden. We have only to look at our President to see how well our progressive tax (with its special provisions for the rich) is working. According to published reports, the Clintons' tax return showed over $500,000 in income, while paying taxes at a 16% tax rate. Surely our president would not disapprove of the flat tax solution, since in effect, he is already practicing it.

Finally, an appropriate label has been placed on the monstrosity we call the tax code -- GREED. I don't think a more anti-family, anti-business, anti-prosperity, anti-success, anti-savings, anti-investment tax code could have been devised had it been planned that way from the start. Ms. Shlaes does what government would never dare do - break down the taxes we pay into the most important aspect of our lives - marriage, children, education, success, retirement, and death. Every taxpayer ought to read this book.

There are probably few people in the country who would disagree that the tax system needs to be seriously overhauled. But, the widely dispersed views of how to do this, the bureaucracratic proceedures required to make any change and the tradition of continuing to do things the same way, seem to prevail. What results are practices like the ones described in THE GREEDY HAND which encourage people to look for ways to reduce their tax burden - Work in one state but live in another that has a lower tax burden and buy goods in one state but ship them to another with a lower tax burden. We will have to reach "a burning platform" in this country to make significant progress, or we will have to educate those in control and teach them a process to get the information they need, reach a consensus, look at alternatives and choose one that will benefit the most people in any economic and social environment that we are likely to experience in the decades to come. This is no small task. There are some lights on the horizon, however. I have just read a wonderful new book, THE 2,000 PERCENT SOLUTION, by Donald Mitchell, Carol Coles and Robert Metz, that describes a process like this. That book also describes why people are "stalled" and unable to make progress. I urge those interested in positive change and more rapid progress to read it.

Amity Shlaes presents in extremely readable fashion a history of taxation in America. She shows how since the Tariff Act of 1917, taxes in this country have come to consume nearly half of everything we earn. Her description of the ills is better than her suggested solutions which don't really break new ground.There is no disputing her thesis however, that the invisible hand of commerce is in a life and death struggle with the greedy hand of government which believes it knows best how money should be spent, and by whom. This book is essential reading for anyone who wants to understand the culture of taxation in this country and ponder the prospects for tax relief.

Do the other reviewers realize that this nation came to be as a result of a revolt over a less than 2% tax on one commodity - tea?

This book, as do some of the other reviewer comments, highlights how accustomed we've become to an effective 50% plus REAL tax rate - factor in sales taxes on food, gas taxes, etc. employment taxes, the previously capped and now unlimited (thank you Clinton) social security tax on earnings and it's no wonder the two wage earner family can't make it.

And by the way, in response to one poorly thought out post, what employment taxes do, other than being convenient for government by taking control away from you and YOUR money, is make most people obvlious to the fact that they're being over taxed, perhaps if we WERE required to write quarterly checks, as we were years ago, our tax system would look quite different. Educate yourselves, starting with this book then THINK!

I am intrigued by the reviewer who stated that we don't appreciate the many services that government provides to us. The reviewer makes "a" point, but misses "the" point. The point is that American's do not freely choose those services. For example, I'd rather not have the FTC taking my tax dollars and using them to chase down value producing entities like Microsoft. I do agree that the people who ride in the cart have responsibility; however, I am concerned about the erosion of respect for private property that causes many to believe that their need is a claim on my earned assets. Electing a politician into office is not a license to confiscate property and redistribute it among those who have courted the politician's favor.