Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
42 of 47 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
How about Callas the Singer ?, October 11, 2000
As a long time Callas fan, I grabbed this book the minute it hit the bookstores. And I read it in about a day. Of course, it is extremely well researched, and probably the definitive book on the Callas-Onassis affair/relationship. Maria the woman is very well depicted, and made a touching, if not sometimes infuriating character and it is obvious that Mr Cage is more interested in her than in Callas the Artist. But in spite of the dichotomy between the two, Callas was an Artist even when she let her love for Onassis lead the way. I may not have been on that fateful cruise, or at the Paris Opera when she sang her last "Norma", but from the recordings, the videos, the interviews, it seems that right until the end, she remained a dedicated musician, always respectful of her Art. This book makes it seem like music became a nuisance for her after she had met Onassis. It doesn't sound that way when one listens to the material she recorded during that time. The "Gioconda" she recorded in Milan a few weeks after she met Onassis and while she was separating from Meneghini is musically and emotionally perfect. It doesn't sound like it was a chore recording it. And all those Verdi, Rossini, Donizetti arias she recorded in the studio after 1959 are musical masterpieces. The voice may be frayed at the edges but she sings with such soul and commitment that it is obvious she loved her music right until the end. Reviews from performances she gave after 1960 are very scarce in the book, and there is one small technical error. Giuletta Simionato, who was interviewed for that book, was a mezzo-soprano, and not a soprano. It is not very important but it shows that music was not Mr Cage's main focus, although it seems to have been very much in Maria Callas' thoughts right until the very end. There is a recording of her singing "Madre pietosa Vergine" from Verdi's "Forza Del Destino" taped in her apartment days before she died and again she treats this material with utmost respect and passion. No mention is made of all the singers she received in her apartment at the end of her life and how she coached them. Singers such as Montserrat Caballe, Shirley Verret or Sylvia Sass have recounted numerous time how Callas would spend time with them and be generous with her advice. Maria the Woman may have had a tragic life but Callas remained an incredibly gifted and generous Artist until the end of her life and that needs to be acknowledged, if only out of respect for what she contributed to the world of music and opera in the past century.
|
|
|
21 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
voyage in the wine-dark sea, January 5, 2001
This book is a convincing portrait of 20th century jet-set society as lived in Greece and Monte Carlo and aboard Aristotle Onassis's yacht Christina. This society comes off as duller than one would imagine, yet thanks to the author's power, I couldn't put the book (which was given me as a Christmas gift) down. Aristotle Onassis is rendered as a figure out of Greek literature. He's as wily, competetive, manipulative as Odysseus--almost always a winner. But in the end he's undone by his own hubris, fulfilling his classic tragic destiny. The parts telling of his childhood in Smyrna are riveting, and terrifying. The story of Turkish massacres of Greeks and Armernians shed light on the ethnic hatred toward all Muslims still felt by many Orthodox Greeks. Onassis is neither a likeable nor an admirable hero, yet Gage does a convincing job of letting us see him in all his Greekness, and somehow we accept that he charmed almost everyone he met. Especially the great prima donna, Maria Callas. Gage doesn't do as well with Callas as with Onassis. I think you wouldn't understand her greatness from reading this book, yet she was very great indeed. To hear Calla sing is to understand all opera is capable of, yet her voice gave out earlier than is the case with most singers for reasons no one understands. Onassis is sometimes blamed for her problems with high notes, but Gage points out that the problems were there before she met Onassis. He doesn't present her as a particularly intelligent, complex or interesting woman, just one undone by her grand passion for Aristotle Onassis. I suspect, given her incredible understanding of tragic heroines in song, there was a lot more to her than this book shows. Worshippers of the late Jacqueline Bouvier Kennedy Onassis (and there are many) are definitely not going to like the portrait painted here!
|
|
|
24 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Yet another Callas book--but it's good, November 20, 2000
The respected Greek-American journalist and biographer Nicholas Gage has written an exhaustive chronicle of perhaps the most sensational episode in Maria Callas' sensational life--her stormy and ultimately tragic involvement with Aristotle Onassis, the Greek shipping magnate.The tale of Callas' life and art, of course, has been told and retold in many volumes of varying worth, but biographically Mr. Gage's carefully researched and verified effort cannot fail to impress. Due to his dual subjects, his chronology largely limits itself to the last two decades of Callas' life (she became seriously involved with Onassis in 1959), but within this time frame he has come up with some startling new revelations, including the astonishing assertion (supported by convincing evidence) that Callas gave birth to a son by Onassis in 1960. The baby died the same day it was born, and this tragic event affected the entire rest of their relationship. There is a reverent, almost mystical tone in Gage's writing about the pair, a feeling that their romance was fated to happen and should have turned out much more happily than it did. This is backed up by the opinions of numerous people close to the couple that Onassis' impulsive pursuit of and marriage to Jacqueline Kennedy was the greatest mistake of his life. Undoubtedly Onassis and Callas come vividly to life in these pages as people, warts and all. About Callas the musician Gage is less convincing. Although he speaks denigratingly about the false stories of the diva that have been uncritically perpetuated by biographers copying from each other, Gage himself does the same on occasion. For example, he repeats the standard tale of the January 1958 Rome Opera "walkout," that Callas was voiceless and struggling against hecklers from the very start of the performance. In fact, as Michael Scott has pointed out, a broadcast tape is readily available of the performance which belies both these contentions. Overall, too, Callas, even with her voice in decline, remained much more interested in singing after she met Onassis than the rather indolent portrait that emerges from these pages would indicate. Post-1960 there were several complete opera recordings, and numerous collections of arias released on disc, and these are just the commercial studio efforts. Still, Callas the artist has been well-served in much other writing, notably that of John Ardoin. Gage's book corrects many more errors than it perpetuates. It is obligatory reading for any fan and, for that matter, anyone who wishes to know more about this eternally glamorous and fascinating pair.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|