15 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Sound quality comparisons, August 9, 2000
This review is from: Green River (20 Bit Mastering) (Audio CD)
"Green River" is a great album, not doubt, but I bought this version (and the new remasters of "Bayou," "Willy," and "Cosmos'") because it was reputed to blow away the sound quality of all others. On a scale of 10, the original LP is a 10, the DCC "Gold" version is a 9.5, this one is 8.5, and the basic CD that's been out for years is a 2 or 3. This one gets the high-frequencies just right, but is nowhere near as warm as the original LP or the DCC version. What DCC gets right and this one doesn't is the mid-range sounds that keep the vocals from sounding unnaturally shrill. The DCC version, on the other hand, doesn't have quite the resolution of this one. But comparing them both to the original LP, the DCC version is much closer to the original tonality. I do have a choice, and I'm going to keep the DCC versions of all four of these LPs and recycle the latest ones. If you don't have a choice, of course, there's no doubt that thse latest remasters are a great, great improvement over what Fantasy has released in the past. Happy listening!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
CCR's Third best, June 13, 2004
This review is from: Green River (20 Bit Mastering) (Audio CD)
Creeedence Clearwater Revival produced 4 outstanding albums. Their best, from my personal perspective, was 'Bayou Country', released early in 1969. 'Green River' is their third best, released in the midst of the Woodstock Festival in August of 1969. Amazingly, before the curtain set on 1969, the band produced 'Willy and the Poor Boys', their fourth best effort. In 1970 'Cosmo's Factory', the album many would claim to be their greatest, but which I would place number two, hit the shelves.
There are two classics offered on 'Green River', the nostalgic title track which hit number two on the national charts, and the ominous yet vibrant 'Bad Moon Rising', which also ascended to number two several months before the 'Green River' disc was released. Two other songs from 'Green River' were promoted as singles, the frentic 'Commotion' (with lyrics even more applicable to today than the late 1960's) which hit number 30, and 'Lodi', a curious laid-back favorite among many of CCR's loyalists, which rose to number 52. 'Green River' and 'Commotion' open the disc in what might be one of the best "one-two punches" ever to open a side of an album, and on the original vinyl, side two opened with 'Bad Moon Rising' and 'Lodi', a sterling complement to side one's intro.
The remaining 5 songs, while not Top-40 material, round out what had become a typical mix for Creedence albums. Creedence is a great cover band, and their rendition of Ray Charles' 'The Night Time Is the Right Time', while not their best cover, is intense and inspired as the album's closer. 'Tombstone Shadow' and 'Sinister Purpose' are the purest blues-rock numbers offered, while 'Wrote a Song For Everyone', lamenting the failure of the wordsmith to communicate with the woman he loves, sounds more like a traditonal country ballad. 'Cross-Tie Walker' effectively plays up the swamp-rock sound parlayed on Creedence hits such as 'Green River' and 'Bad Moon Rising', but with a less catchy melody, yet interesting lyrics.
John Fogerty and his bandmates had the capacity to sing songs that dealt with difficult and desperate themes, yet still maintain a postive, inviting, "down-home" atmosphere. As with 'Bayou Country', 'Green River' is brief in length, but lacking Fogarty's extended guitar solo's that appeal to many CCR fans, and alienate others. While 'Bayou Country' felt underground and radical, 'Greeen River' feels commercial.
My version of this disc is "mastered in analog utilizing the 20-bit K2 Super Coding System" developed by JVC. I don't know what all that means, but I can tell you this: the sound is exceptional, and I personally will make every effort to obtain recordings using this technology in the future. The jewel case is enveloped in a decorative cardboard sleeve, and the superfluous liner notes make the consumer's desire for a lyrics sheet even more compelling.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
about the remastering of this fine music, August 16, 2000
By A Customer
This review is from: Green River (20 Bit Mastering) (Audio CD)
So you say you want to travel back in time and sit next to the engineers as they mix this music from fresh tapes? You want to hear the nuance of the (now vintage) equipment more clearly than you imagined possible?
Buy this series.
My local radio station still plays the older CDs. No offence to those who produced them (many years ago) but there is no comparison. If you own and enjoy those older CDs, buy the new ones.
Thank you Shigeo Miyamoto and Tamaki Beck for taking such care with these beautiful recordings (the entire series).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No