0 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
First Thomas Boggs Book, October 26, 2006
A Kid's Review
This review is from: Green Roses (Paperback)
(ending kind of given away)
So I found out about Thomas Boggs through pure chance, and immediately wanted to read one of his books. Green Roses was cheaper than his other novel, Tokyo Vanilla, so I took a chance, and...
Disappointment.
The ending was very, very abrupt, and the entire novel is completely centric on the main character's feelings, as if his entire family didn't even exist. Tim (main character) also has some kind of...personality change...around the middle, which I'm sure was explained somewhere within the oh-so-complex storyline...
Did I say 'complex'? I meant simple and there for a sole purpose; sex. There wasn't much emotional content unless you could read it from the physical description, which wouldn't have been a problem if the characters had about five times as much depth. I will say that the steamy scenes are moderately hot, but there isn't enough of a 'story' to balance it out. Green Roses, in my opinion, is borderlining on being smut.
THAT would have been fine with me as well, but it didnt' begin like that at all. In fact, I was expecting it to be a great novel from the way the book began. Then it was just like Boggs decided to...stop. On the better hand, it's definitely fanfiction material, the kind of book that someone else could have really brought into a brilliant light.
Yes, a light that would have focused more on the emotions of the other characters, maybe. Like how did Tim's mother feel when word was getting around camp that he was seeing a Japanese boy? Or Doug's (the 'friend') behavior around Tim after he started to hear the rumors? Or SATORU, MAYBE, AFTER HE DECIDED TO NEVER SEE TIM AGAIN?!
Just a disappointing, depressing novel. Full of possibilities, but they all died when Boggs said 'nah...'. Good read if you want some quick smut and an ending that tried a little too hard to be 'tragic', bad read if you're looking for something to READ. If you can buy it cheap, give it a try, but be cautioned.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No