Most Helpful Customer Reviews
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Ahhhhahhh...so there is more to Green than meets the eye..., July 1, 2010
This review is from: Green Witch (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
As an Alice Hoffman fan of the first order, I picked Green Witch prepared to add it to my lengthy list of her books which I adore and would recommend hands down. As other reviewers have pointed out, it's pure prose poetry.
What I didn't realize is that it's a sequel. I recommend reading Green Angel first (I will have to do that retroactively.) As a stand alone there is simply too much left unexplained. The five sections - Stone Witch, Sky Witch, Rose Witch, River Witch, and Green Witch, which comprise the slim Green Witch volume feel almost parenthetical to a far greater tale - as, indeed, they are. And though the ending is hopeful, as is true with every Alice Hoffman story, Green Witch has such a tragic overall cast that instead of feeling - oh, "things will be all right despite everything for these characters", I felt almost the opposite - despite their finding one another, coming together, being a "family" - nothing can ever be all right again, and they may survive and love, but they won't really live...
Here's what I think Scholastic should do. (My humble opinion.) Have Ms. Hoffman complete a third book, one that does bring the story full-circle, and has a more upbeat, maybe even a little funny at moments, overall feeling. Call it Green Garden, or Green Spirit... Then package the three as a trilogy.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Book Review: LibraryLoungeLizard.com, March 23, 2010
This review is from: Green Witch (Hardcover)
I loved Green Angel and I was so happy to see the sequel because Green definitely had more to tell...
In the first book Green loses her family in a horrible disaster that occurs when they visit a local city that is set ablaze by terrorist type people called "The Horde". The Horde despise any type of growth and advancement in civilization. In Green Witch we find out more about them and their mission:
"Repent...Don't even try to fight because heaven is on our side."
A chilling similarity to the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks that parallels the terrorists opinions that we deserved their hate and wrath.
What I love about these two books is that they are about hope and love and that with the help of those around us we can eventually rise above the despair of losing people we love.
Green mourns the life before the fires and can't see that she will ever get over her loss. She tattoos her body with roses and thorns and closes herself off to the rest of world. It is only when she decides to start helping others in need, animals and people alike, that she truly starts to break through her own grief and regret.
In Green Witch Green sets out to find two people disappear from her life...Heather a school mate whose brother asks for Greens help and Diamond, the boy who brought love back into Green's life. There are secrets in both disappearances and Green knows that in order to complete her journey she must find the truth.
Magical, magical writing that you will find yourself re-reading and perhaps writing down certain meaningful and lovely passages that you want to remember...
"Dreams are like air. They never leave you. It takes less than nothing to begin."
Both books are just barely over a hundred pages...they are more about quality than quantity and Greens story will leave a lasting impression. I have never had a student that I recommended the books to return them unread.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Green Grows Up, July 1, 2010
This review is from: Green Witch (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
In GREEN ANGEL, Green loses her family and herself to an all-encompassing disaster in the city from fundamentalist zealots (kinda like 9/11, but with destruction amplified many times over). After a long and desperate time, she begins to heal with the help of an old neighbor and Diamond, a young man she loves. With her gift for making things grow, she is again Green, not Ash, the name she gave herself when she was most desperate.
In GREEN WITCH, Green now longs only for the other half of her heart: Diamond. In order to find her other half, she seeks out the counsel of four witches: Stone Witch, Sky Witch, Rose Witch, and River Witch. Each one shows her by word and deed what she must do to find Diamond. They help her, but she must also help herself...and others besides Diamond.
Hoffman's poetic prose is greener than Green...verdant, lush, all-encompassing and redolent with the scent and substance of loamy magic. Her imagery combines the tangible with the magical, such as the different kinds of paper Green creates for her stories, depending on the person involved. The Rose Witch's paper is made with rose water "so that the pages are tinged with flecks of crimson." She adds rose petals to it as well. Don't you want this paper? I do.
I almost want to live in Green's world, even though the Horde (the fundamental zealots who want to repress women and learning and individual thought and technology) is an imminent threat. Like Green, Hoffman forges a place of peace and exquisite beauty from the ashes and it's a lovely haven, one I wish to enter again and again.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|