23 of 26 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
sad but intriguing tale, June 3, 2006
This review is from: Grievous Angel : An Intimate Biography of Gram Parsons (Paperback)
I really enjoyed this book and found it the most user friendly of all the books written about country rock legend Gram Parsons. It presents him in a realistic light, warts and all. He was a remarkably talented young man who had it all. Unfotrunately the one thing he lacked was self-discipline and that ended up being the end of him. Nonetheless, the musical and social/personal journey he had in his short life make for great reading. I highly recommmend it. I found it fun to be playing some GP music softly in the background while I read it. This really made some cool ambience.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
A Disappointing Work of Historical Fiction, January 9, 2009
This review is from: Grievous Angel : An Intimate Biography of Gram Parsons (Paperback)
Sadly, Gram Parsons becomes a fictional character in his own biography. I was really hoping this would be a better read then the Ben Fong-Torres bio, but boy was I wrong. I appreciate Jessica Hundley's effort, but this "bio" is made up at best and sheds no light on the Southern Gothic story that is Gram & the Snively clan. The writing and research are sloppy and lazy. She tends to use clunky, overly dramatic descriptions often ("Gram looked out at the upturned faces; a hundred eyes watched as his hands played and watched his face as he held a note in his throat. Something that had been inside him suddenly slipped together again. He felt his lungs and his cheeks go hot. He smiled, gazing into the pale face of a girl in front for just a moment too long, felt her surrender, saw the boys and their envy, and for the first time, felt whole.") Ugh. Gram says and thinks a lot of things in this book. He also winks, smiles, stares at himself in the mirror, thinks deeply about things, etc.
Important facts are downplayed or left out (we don't find out that Gram Connor is immediately adopted by his stepfather and becomes Gram "Parsons" until way into the book -- he's just Gram until the "oh yeah, forgot to mention" moment); the Connor clan and his relationship with them is barely mentioned, etc.
Also, editing is pretty terrible, especially in a book about a musician --we're treated to Arthur Conley's "That's Alright, Mama" & Bourdeleaux Bryant's "Love Hurts" (it's Arthur Crudup & Boudleaux Bryant). At one point, even Gram's little sister Avis ("Little Avis") becomes "Little Avril" on page 190. Some accepted facts are wrong -- in Fong-Torres' book, Bernie Leadon sings the hymn "Farther Along" at Clarence White's funeral, a very poignant and touching moment. In this book, it's not Bernie but Gram, who "sick in his guts and sad to the core" starts to sing "an old hymn" as others join in, "fill(ing) their lungs with their grief."
I really, really wanted to like this book. What I can't fathom is why Jessica Hundley decided to make most of it up. What this amounts to is a fairy-tale fanbook with only some basis in the truth. How about some interviews? The Snivelys are still in the citrus business in Florida. I'm sure there are some Connors still around in Tennessee. Emmylou, Road Mangler, Bernie Leadon, Hillman, McGuinn, James Burton, Roland White, Merle Haggard, are all still alive. Why not travel to Winter Haven, Jax, Waycross, Tennessee, etc., and get the feel for what Gram experienced? What's with all the "fan" interviews? Who cares?
Unfortunately, what this book does is turn Gram into a semi-fictional character who somehow became an influential musician. Simply making up words and thoughts for Gram does nothing to highlight the complex and troubled character he must have been. It only makes me wish Jessica Hundley had written an actual biography and not a book based on a true story. It hurts me to say this because I admire the fact that Ms. Hundley wanted to share a story and seems to truly love the subject, but the book is pretty terrible -- in many ways, it's her story, not Gram's. Get Ben Fong-Torres' book instead.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No