21 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Guadalcanal: The U,S, Marines in World War II: A Pictorial Tributr, September 1, 2007
This review is from: Guadalcanal: The U.S. Marines in World War II: A Pictorial Tribute (Hardcover)
Book Review
Eric Hammel, St. Paul, MN: Zenith Press, 2007, 160 pp. Maps, Glossary, Bib., Index. $34.95.
Hammel has written some excellent books covering the war in the British Solomon Islands and in particular on the big island of Guadalcanal Yet this work is different as it a pictorial history or photo study of war on that sun baked island, but it is also provides a brief narrative history. The work also covers the outer-islands of Tulagi, Tanambogo, Gavutu and Florida, but not to the extent of his photo examples of Guadalcanal.
His previous pictorial book, Bloody Tarawa, also a narrative history with 250 photographs, is a great addition of the pictorial history of war on another deadly island, another excellent book.
Yet, the Guadalcanal book is better for one reason. His Chinese printer used a better grade of paper than on Eric's Tarawa work with the result in that the photographs are much sharper. Hammel's photo collection is probably the best private assemblage of photographs from the campaign; most of his photographs came from the files of the National Archives, the Marine Corps Historical Branch or the Marine Corps University. Many I had never seen before as even though I have studied the Solomon campaigns for 45 years, and I have many Guadalcanal photographs in my own collection that do not appear in Hammel's hardback.
2d Lt. Thayer Soule an experienced photographer was the chief photographer of the 1st Marine Division and was assigned to D-2 Section (Intelligence); he landed on Guadalcanal on D-Day. Lt. Soule is credited with have taken many of the early photographs. (See Thayer Soule, Shooting The Pacific War) He had two of his still photographers, Privates Robert Howard and Edward A. Sexton assigned to the assault units for still camera work. Ed Sexton to the 2d Battalion, 5th Marines, for the invasion of Tulagi, and Bob Howard for the landing at Gavutu with the Paramarines. Sexton got some fine shots of the Tulagi Campaign, but Howard was too busy on Gavutu to take photographs; he was too busy trying to stay alive. The first eight hours on Gavutu, the Chutes had 50% causalities.
On the third page he shows four marines carrying a man on the stretcher, but no caption. I'll provide the details. They are all from Company A, 1st Battalion, 6th Marines. The photo was taken in a coconut grove near Tassafonga Point on 28 January 1943. On the stretcher was wounded Lt. Baine P. Kerr; in the left front was Cpl. Berndt, left rear, Plt/Sgt. Joseph A. Cado, right rear, Pvt. Barkowski, and right front Cpl. Herman Burks.
On page 29, he had the caption wrong, it reads ..."mounted light machine gun overlooks a likely landing beach in southwestern Tulagi." No way ! That gun was on Gavutu Island, and the photo was taken in the spring of 1942 by Lac. Cliff Searle with the RAAF. On page 32, he lists 12 Japanese POWs as "Imperial Navy infantrymen were taken prisoner during the two day battle of Tulagi" There were only four combatants who were taken prisoner from that battle, the others were laborers from the construction units.
The photograph on the last page "Here lies a devil dog" was not taken at Guadalcanal, but on Bougainville Island.
These are simple mistakes, but are not a distraction. The book itself is a gem and it is highly recommended.
Stanley C. Jersey, author, Hell's Islands: The Untold Story of Guadalcanal
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
This unique combination makes for a choice pick not just for military libraries but for general-interest holdings, October 19, 2007
This review is from: Guadalcanal: The U.S. Marines in World War II: A Pictorial Tribute (Hardcover)
The six-month Guadalcanal campaign was the longest operation the U.S. Marines faced in the pacific, and many books have been written by participants and reporters alike. GUADALCANAL: THE U.S. MARINES IN WORLD WAR II is a pictorial tribute: this means a collection of unusual vintage photos, many of which have never before seen print - paired with critically acclaimed military historian Eric Hammel's expert analysis. This unique combination makes for a choice pick not just for military libraries but for general-interest holdings which would make at least one such visual tribute accessible to the public eye rather than specialty examination alone.
Diane C. Donovan
California Bookwatch
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No