From Publishers Weekly
A class of young schoolchildren learns a spirited lesson about growing up, creatively delivered by Australian author French, a former kindergarten teacher with an insightful grasp of this age group's questioning minds. When Sam brings his infant brother to school for Show and Tell, the teacher, Mr. Judd, reminds the incredulous class that they, too, were once babies. The students bring in their baby pictures and create a photo gallery, rendered in endearing detail by Rawlins (My Place), and then engage in a game of who's who, matching the baby to the classmate ("We guessed Sacha, because he still has the same smile. And Mara, because her hair is as orange as oranges"). Rawlins offers visual clues-Tess wears her hair the same way she did as an infant; Braydon bares his belly, just as he does in his baby photo-and Mr. Judd gives hints for the "tricky ones." But one photograph remains a mystery-who is that sailor-suited cutie? When the class realizes it's Mr. Judd, the children plunge into a pastel-colored reverie, imagining their mustachioed teacher as a baby (complete with facial hair). The children's excitement about this revelation ("Mr. Judd used to eat mushy food,"; "Mr. Judd used to have yucky diapers") drives home French's simple message that "even grownups were babies once." For every child who's ever asked the question, "Was I a baby?" this book is a delightful answer. Ages 4-6.
Copyright 2002 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
PreSchool-Grade 1-When Sam takes his baby brother to school, the other students and their teacher are delighted. The class watches as Jake is fed and bathed by his mother. Then they talk about things babies do and what they need. This prompts Mr. Judd to request that they all bring a photo of themselves as babies, and a game of who's who follows. The easy-to-read text and warm, lively illustrations depict a frolicsome, multicultural cast of youngsters; the colorful spread of their pictures as babies is particularly engaging. Creative and hip Mr. Judd is a teacher with pizzazz.
Leslie Barban, Richland County Public Library, Columbia, SCCopyright 2002 Reed Business Information, Inc.