Customer Reviews

Guilty by Reason of Insanity: Inside the Minds of Killers

5 star:		(18)
4 star:		(10)
3 star:		(9)
2 star:		(5)
1 star:		(7)

 

 

I find the biases and filters with which other reviewers came to this book amusing and not very helpful. The fact is, Dr. Lewis's book is neither as great nor as bad as many of them make out.

Yes, she does speak as a feeling person as much as a professional, and yes, she sometimes makes herself seem far more naive than I suspect she must have been. Also, of necessity the book parades a rogues gallery of killers -- male and female -- and their gruesome crimes before us.

On the one hand, this is not a scientific paper, it is a popular book for the lay reader. And nevertheless, Dr. Lewis has several very important points to make. Most and perhaps all of the death row inmates she has studied not only came from horrid socioeconomic and psychological backgrounds, but they appear to have suffered brain damage before birth, at birth, or in accidents or due to abuse since. Some appeared to suffer genuine seizures and mental blackouts; others, much as Dr. Lewis's training and inclination led her to resist the notion, genuinely appeared to have multiple personalities. Her conversion on this point by flesh-and-blood evidence is an instructive process.

These facts raise interesting questions about criminal responsibility and culpability, ones the legal system is not anywhere near prepared to acknowledge and weigh in its decisions. The conclusion is not that society should free these damaged souls, but perhaps that the nature of their punishment and treatment could be better informed. Dr. Lewis voices strong if not terribly coherent criticisms of these failings.

So I found the book engrossing and thought-provoking. Unfortunately, my hardbound copy suffers from the growing plague in contemporary books of computer spell-check-dependent typos. There are references to "grizzly murder" (112) and "grizzliest murders" (258 -- though the adjective is spelled correctly on page 284), and to a fetus's navel "chord" (264). Most unfortunate for a Jewish author, one reads of "a minion of Hassidim (142 -- the word is "minyan," editors!), and even worse for a doctor, we find the sentence: "A death row psychiatrist's allegiance is torn between Hypocrites and the state" (187). Hypocritic Oath, anyone?

Despite these minor irritations, this is a useful and readable book.

Though I'm a proponent of the death penalty, reading this book in the last 24 hours, I have reasons to question it, especially in the context of abused criminals who reenact their abuse onto others. Lewis has made me question my cut and dry attitude and has shown me the gapping hole in my bag of logic, truth, and criminology. Guilty By Reason of Insanity leaves me with more questions than answers. Though this isn't a genre that I read, Lewis's writing has me hungering for more answers.

Psychiatrist Dorothy Lewis Provides a fairly imformative account of the lives of violent criminals, the causes of their behavior, and their punishment. This book is based on her experiences interviewing murderers on death row. For a far more informative, more profound, and persuasive account of violence, its causes and punishment, I suggest reading James Gilligan's book VIOLENCE: REFLECTIONS ON A NATIONAL EPIDEMIC.

This book is valid for professions in criminal justice as well as mental health.
Lewis is not writing this book to empathise with victims, she wrote it to educate people on behind the scene information that the media does not portray.
Background information about the author is not overbearing or irrelevant.
I would reccommend this to open minded, pro capital punishment, enlightened, MATURE readers with a passion for human physiology, psychology and experience.

I borrow the word "flawed" from another one of the reviewers. She's right. It is flawed. This book is at once incredible and frustrating. It makes some important points, it's written from a well-educated and well-informed perspective, but it "feels" less rigorous than would satisfy me... not because it isn't, but because the author's style is very conversational, even at times like stream-of-consciousness writing, wandering from point to point without following a clearly defined path.

I appreciate that the author's personality is so "present" in the text. But, at the same time, the conversation she's having with her reader could do with more focus. I was both happy to go along with her wandering style, and also constantly wishing she'd stop and tell me more about her points (support them) and return to them to help conclude her delivery with strength.

Nevertheless, this book was, for me, an excellent introduction to the psychology of violence and the "big secret" kept about killers on Death Row: that they're mildly to severely neurologically impaired. Almost every one of them.

Dorothy O. Lewis has dedicated her life's work to study why human beings murder. Her impressive, excellent book "Guilty by Reason of Insanity: A Psychiatrist Explores the Minds of Killers" is a harrowing read. It is shocking to learn about the actual acts of murder. They are usually seen as nothing but completely senseless evil acts-until the appalling, perverted physical and sexual violence and abuses, which these murderers had endured as children, come to light. Exposed to brutal, merciless whippings, beatings, and abused in abhorrent ways as sexual slaves-some of them through being sodomized-they had to manage to survive their childhoods from hell in a constant state of terror. Many people still want to believe that people are born evil; or that evilness afflicts a person out of nowhere; or that some innate evilness makes a human being kill. But that is not true.
The murderers whom we get to know in this gripping book have been through unspeakable horrors. They have damaged brains and mental illnesses. But the decisive and common factor for murderous acts is the experience of extremely traumatic childhood abuse. In many cases the barbaric, perverted torture caused the mind of the tortured child to split into multiple personalities. Dorothy Lewis, trained at Yale in a traditional, psychoanalytic way, could at first not recognize this devastating reality that helped these children survive and dissociate from their unbearable ordeals. Her interviews, wherein she gains a murderer's trust so that the split personalities dare to come out and communicate with her-with their own names and characteristics, like a different way to talk, to look, to move-are stunning, shocking, and painfully fascinating.
Why do we look at murderers only as evil, perverted people who just must be put away or even silenced forever through the death penalty? Why don't we try to gain all possible information about what produced their crimes? To understand what makes a murderer kill does not mean to excuse the crime or to let him or her out of jail. Society has the right to be protected. But we could learn so much from every murderer about the origins of terrible killings and how to prevent them-if we felt the responsibility to find out the reality and truth, and the reasons behind them. Thus, we could create a new, vitally important awareness about the devastating dangers and consequences of permitting violence against children.
It is a great loss for humanity's growth that society is so blind, deaf and without any compassion for the ordeals of the victims of unfathomably monstrous childhood torture, which these murderers had to endure over and over again. In their interviews with Dorothy Lewis, they shared what happened to them often for the first time in their lives. Many of them could not remember any of it and could not explain why they had scars on their backs, their behinds and other parts of their bodies. Only dissociated parts, formed by their minds to help them survive, remembered the horrific abuses. It was frustrating to read how long it took and how skilled the interviewer had to ask her questions until these harrowingly mistreated human beings would share anything about their past-which they did only when they had come to trust this bright and sensitive psychiatrist.
It was mind-boggling to read that they did not want to reveal what they had suffered as children because they were afraid to paint their parents in a `bad light' and to loose their families if they did so-which they feared especially when they were close to their executions and any information about their own plights might have saved their lives. Their parents were nothing but relieved if the truth remained a secret, hidden away-even if it meant that their child would be executed and had no chance of having his or her life spared through information that would throw light on their violent insanity.
It was moving and interesting to read how Dorothy Lewis describes her path from her confining training at Yale in the `Freudian tradition' to arrive at her realizations, brought about by her experiences through these interviews-that human beings, who suffer traumatic, barbaric abuse in childhood can become violent murderers and people with multiple minds.
Murders are nothing else but the visible final acts of too many acts of agonizing violence inflicted on powerless, helpless, defenseless, innocent children-a reality which society does not wish to recognize. Society only takes note, often in sensational ways, of this final act and how to punish the criminal who committed it-but does not wish to be informed about all the crimes of their parents and other caretakers that led to this crime.
Dorothy Lewis has worked together with Jonathan Pinkus, who has written the book "Base Instincts." They found three factors that need to come together to entice a murderous act: child abuse, mental illness, and brain damage. As I read about the cruelty and violence committed against these children, on a regular, often-daily basis, I wondered who would think that any adult could survive such ongoing torture, continuing for years, without severely damaging and traumatic consequences for his brain, mind, soul, body and sanity. Adults, tortured like that, would find sympathy and understanding, maybe even help. A child, in the possession and at the complete mercy of merciless, insane parents or other cruel, perverted abusers with power over the child, cannot find help or sympathy in his/her childhood-and rarely in court. Justice is a concept that never even touches these lives.

This book makes an interesting matched pair with Richard Rhodes "Why They Kill."

Rhodes examines the social roots of violence, and Dr. Lewis examines the neurologic roots of violence. She pretty much convinced me (not that I needed much convincing) that we're executing a large number of people whose elevators don't go to the top story. My support for the death penalty, already weak, was basically extinct by the time I finished "Guilty by Reason of Insanity."

Quibbles? Sure. Even in a popular book, it would be nice to have a more detailed explanation of the neuroscience underlying her work. Lewis tosses in the occasional technical explanation, but if you're at all interested in the medicine behind the story, you're not going to be satisfied (I'm going to take a look at "Behavioral Neurology," written by her mentor and co-worker Jonathan Pincus).

Lewis is also forbidden (apparently for legal and/or ethical reasons) for talking about some of her most famous patients, including John Lennon's killer, and apparently Ted Bundy. They get mentioned, but not discussed in any detail.

It's also a woman's story told in a woman's way. I like women (in fact I'm married to one and have one for a daughter), but there are times when the male reader will feel like yelling "I don't *care* how you felt about all this, just tell me what happened!" :-)

A very interesting look into the process of researching criminal minds. Dr.Lewis maintains a balence of scientific terms and telling a case by case story. If you have thought about going into this realm professionally, then this book can give you agood look into the types of scenerios delt with. I thought the focus of child abuse and multiple personaility/dissociative disorder was facinating, hard to put down!! Also check out her partners work Dr. Jonathen Pincus, for further reading

This book takes an interesting probe into the minds of psychopaths. If we learn anything by the research done, it should be that insanity is no defense, and parents are indirectly the cause of a killers behavior through systematic abuse, both mental and physical, whether they inflict it or allow it by someone else. Lewis interviews and reviews the history of some of Americas most vicious and pathatic killers of our time, and gives sound reasoning as to why they do what they do, and why they should never be let out. A must read for anyone interested in Psychology, Criminalogy, or a look into the thoughts and actions of killers.

This is a must read book for anyone interested in crime or the analysis of the criminal mind. It is more than informative and provides many different theories as to why people kill. It allows the reader to better appreciate different "mental disorders" and the application of our legal systems. It leaves you thinking and sympathizing with those who we deem to be different from what we see as normal. It is an excellent book for psychology or law students.