Customer Reviews

The Unknown Gulag: The Lost World of Stalin's Special Settlements

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

We well know that, before the Gulag, there was Solovki. But, as Viola shows, between Solovki and the Gulag there were the spets - poselki (special villages) built by two million peasant kulak in 1930 and 1931, after they were forcibly removed from their villages and dropped in remotest Siberia without food or shelter. Some half-million souls died in these deadly precursors to the Gulag, whose existence was defended as a State Secret until recently - long after the crimes of the Gulag had been well chronicled by Solzhenitsyn and others. Thank fully, there are tenacious researchers like Viola bringing such things to light, honoring the victims in a society that seems determined to forget. (Reviewed in Russian Life)

Gulag is the abbreviation for the vast agglomeration of prisons, penal camps and settlements that held the millions of citizens the Marxist/Leninist Communists enslaved. This scholarly work covers the establishment of the settlements populated by the expropriated "kulaks" -- rich peasants, the definition of which changed constantly.

Millions of people, mostly entirely families, denounced as enemies of the socialists were arrested because they owned a cow, a tractor, had employees, had more goods than a neighbor, were simply disliked or because a Communist functionary needed to meet a quota. They were forced into box cars without adequate food, water or sanitation and sent hundreds or thousands of miles away into exile. Thousands died enroute, still more thousands were executed. And many more thousands died when they were forced to labor in forests, mines and on primitive farms in the name of socialist glory.

Lynne Viola has conducted extensive research, including many hours in the formerly sealed archives of the security organs. Her unadorned prose is all the more horrifying: "The survivors noted that the people whom Soviet sources labeled non-able-bodied and who some of the bosses called "ballast" were the most vulnerable during the famine." There are extensive quotes from the letters of the exiled, letters which of course were confiscated by the socialist authorities. There are excerpts from the endless reports of the bureaucrats who spent enormous time blaming others for their failures to extract more work from their slaves.

Most people will be unable to tolerate reading "The Unknown Gulag". It is not likely to find favor among the left-wing who prefer to pretend that socialism didn't kill and enslave hundreds of millions of people in Europe, Asia and Africa. For the few who can deal with the truth, Lynne Viola has performed a great service.

Jerry

I got interested in the subject of the gulag by reading a book called "Cannibal Island" which told the horrifying story of one settlement in the gulag.

This book is a more scholarly and detailed examination of the gulag. It is a truth "that was suppressed for nearly sixty years, locked in Soviet archives and buried in the memories of frightened survivors" (p 2).

The communist party, and Stalin in particular, declared war on the kulak class during the 1930's. A kulak was a slang word for a tightfisted person, and the communists were certain that the country would flourish if only they could be rid of those peasants who hoarded food and goods.

In fact, the country was in a state of chaos and the people who were branded kulaks were as likely to be already starving as hoarding anything.
Yet, "In the violent context of the First Five-Year Plan, the countryside became a foreign country to be invaded, occupied, and conquered" (p 32).

Millions were swept up, wrenched from their families and their land, sent in over packed trains to the gulags. And millions died. Typhus and smallpox, exhaustion and starvation claimed the poor peasants who were sent to the gulag.

In their desperation, many tried to escape the gulag, only to perish in the vast emptiness of Siberia. Some rebellions occurred, and were swiftly put down. The dry reports from those in charge make for grim reading, containing such statistics as half of the women had ceased to menstruate due to hunger (p 133).

I won't add much to what was said above. The book is well-written and I've never seen such thorough documentation in any non-academic book. But...it is tough going: it's full of /extremely/ detailed lists, numbers of settlers, how many went to which region, etc., etc. Full of so many different acronyms that even the student of Russian history will find it very difficult to keep up with. There is a five page glossary of terms and abbreviations such as OGPU, DGO, GPU, GAVO, GAOPDF AO, GAAO, GARF, RGASPI, etc., etc., etc.

The only comment I'd make about the style is this - although Dr. Viola appears to be extremely fluent in Russian (bravo) due to the sources she quotes, she uses a vexing and unorthodox transliteration system. The part of this seemingly self-made system that bothered me the most was that although all the systems I've seen use the apostrophe ' to indicate the 'soft sound' and the " to indicate 'hard sound' she uses the quote mark sometimes when there is no soft sound in the original word. For example, on page xxiii she writes ob' "edinennoe, which indeed has a hard sound after the b but there is no possibility in Russian for a soft sound + a hard sound immediately following. There are many more examples. The other unusual parts of this system are only a little less irritating to students of the Russian language and if you are familiar with the standard transliteration systems you will know what I mean but if you don't know Russian you wouldn't care about it.

There are only 193 pages before all the appendix and notes section, but luckily the Amazon discounted price makes it not too expensive for a short book. Good for the researcher, but not for the person who is just interested in reading about the subject.