1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Lost River Culture, July 20, 2010
This review is from: Gunboat on the Yangtze: The Diary of Captain Glenn F. Howell of the USS Palos, 1920-1921 (Paperback)
Just the name of the great river Yangtze is evocative. It conjures up images of junks crowded with peasants plying their living and frequently spending most of their lives on these creaking boats, and war lords ruling with a heavy hand. In the early 20th century, a number of foreign nations had economic and religious interests in the interior of China, and the mighty Yangtze was how they accessed these interests. To protect their citizens who were exploiting the Chinese; Britain, France, Italy, Germany, Japan, and the United States all sent gunboats to ply the river. These gunboats, all necessarily with very shallow drafts, steamed up river as far as 1000 miles from the sea, climbing up over rapids through the majestic gorges of the upper Yangtze.
USS PALOS PG-16 (redesignated PR-1 in 1928) was one of those small gunboats. From June 1920 to September 1921, PALOS was commanded by LCDR Glenn F. Howell, who kept a fairly detailed diary. Howell, a relatively junior officer, had to deal with the ordinary challenges of command; recalcitrant sailors, broken pumps, ornery boilers, and difficult navigation; in addition, he was "America" to much senior officers of other Navies, diplomats, missionaries, and Chinese war lords. All of this without recourse to instructions from the State Department or his chain of command. Frequently his decisions had potential impact well beyond his horizons.
Many readers will be familiar with RADM Kemp Tolley's writings (Cruise of the Lanakai, The Yangtze Patrol, and others), and Richard McKenna's Sand Peebles which tells a fictitious tale of a "sister" of PALOS (USS SAN PABLO) set in about the same time-frame. However, the less well-known Howell's diary adds new dimension, texture, and cultural observations to the works of Tolley and McKenna.
Editor Noble does a workmanlike job of putting context and important detail into Howell's descriptions. A short (176 pages) and easy read, it is nonetheless quite interesting for what it covers. The China of the 1920s, especially once you got away from the coast, was as remote a place as one could find on planet earth. Communications was difficult, if not impossible. Howell's descriptions of the landscape that has already been permanently altered by the Three Gorges Dam will be useful to scholars of the future. His cultural observations are remarkable for a naval officer not trained as an anthropologist. All in all, a good read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No