Customer Reviews

Guru, Psychotherapist and Self: A Comparative Study of the Guru-Disciple Relationship and the Jungian Analytic Process

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Anyone who has ever tried to explain the subtle transmission of wisdom between teacher and student knows how daunting a challenge this endeavor can be. In his book Guru, Psychotherapist and Self, Dr. Peter Coukoulis almost effortlessly brings to light the nuances that take place between guru and discipline and the therapeutic process that occurs in the analytic relationship. Using story, myth and deep personal insights he synthesizes a great Eastern tradition with one more familiar to us in the West. He particularly draws from Aurobindo to help us understand the different ways great gurus like Ramakrishna and the Tibetan yogi Milarepa gave guidance to their disciples. Dr. Coukoulis, a Jungian analyst, shows how therapy can go beyond working through the transference and help patients achieve conscious realization of the Self.

Guru, Psychotherapist and Self is a penetrating psychological analysis of two of the most intimate and complex relationships between a wise teacher and a willing student. This book helps mend the split that many of us suffer from the lack of having enlightened mentors. Best of all readers of this excellent book need not have advanced degrees in psychology or consciousness studies to enjoy it and profit from it. Dr. Coukoulis distills the essence of these healing relationships into a highly readable, fascinating and thoroughly insightful understanding of how wisdom of the Self is transmitted in different healing and spiritual relationships. In addition to his scholarship Dr. Coukoulis' writing is clear and uncomplicated. I loved the way his message transcends the subject and gave me a personal experience of how gurus and analysts work with their students. As a practical matter I also appreciated the generous glossary that defines psychological and Sanskrit terms he appended at the end of the book.

I highly recommend this book to anyone interested in comparative religion, psychotherapy, spirituality and the field of intersubjectivity. This book is just the medicine needed in a world dangerously divided by cultural differences.

Review: Coukoulis, Peter P. Guru, Psychotherapist & Self

Carl Jung cautioned Westerners that embracing Eastern religions and practices were difficult due to vast cultural differences. Dr. Peter Coukoulis, long-time Jungian analyst, bridges that gap by providing insightful links between traditional Western analytical psychology and the Eastern dynamic of the guru/disciple relationship.
Through the lens of Jungian Psychology, Dr. Coukoulis focuses on two great gurus: Ramakrishna, the devotional guru, and the legendary Tibetan guru, Milarepa. In both cases, they had extraordinary relationships with their disciples. At first, the guru/disciple encounter is one of teacher and pupil couched in humility, respect and learning, but as the relationship develops, it meshes into a psychic force that is highly spiritual and beneficial to both parties. Eventually the disciple does not depend on the physical presence and constant guidance of the guru and moves into a relationship with his or her own inner guru.
In Jungian terms, the analyst and the analysant have a similar relationship which is called transference. The extended purpose of psychoanalysis is for the analysant to move from the dependent, guiding relationship with his or her analyst to a discovery of the Self or Collective Unconscious. Both the analyst and the analysant reach higher spiritual dimensions in the psychoanalytic process.
Dr. Coukoulis points out in his book that dreams, meditation and active imagination play an important role for both the guru/disciple and the analytic relationship. He covers these topics extensively as he examines stories, myths and processes that are the same and different between the two traditions. He makes a genuine case for insights from both.
Sri Aurobindo was a great influence on the author of this book. Dr. Coukoulis spent a year studying and reflecting at the Aurobindo Ashram in India. It was there that he saw the profound connection between East and West, the relevance of the guru, the experience of the disciple, the spiritual dynamics of such a relationship and the important comparison and contribution to Jungian Psychology.
This book is essential to anyone in or contemplating formal analysis and also to those who have a connection and desire to engage in their own journey of transformation and self-awareness. It is a book about the most intimate connection between human beings that leads from transference to individuation to the ultimate realization of the Self.

Reviewed by Diana Klimek, Ph.D. student in Depth Psychology at Pacifica Graduate Institute, Santa Barbara, California. .



.