Most Helpful Customer Reviews
15 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
The rating I gave says it all., June 6, 2002
A Kid's Review
This review is from: The Gypsy Game (Hardcover)
I read The Egypt Game and I really loved that book, so I read this book right away since it is the sequal. That was a bad decision. This is one of the most terrible books I have ever, ever read! I really liked the characters in The Egypt Game because they were so realistic and likable. The characters in The Gypsy Game are supposedly the same, but it seems that very unrealistic and unlikable characters jumped into the book and called themselves April, Toby, and the rest of them. Also, because of the title, I thought this book was actually going to be about a gypsy game. If that's what you're hoping, you might as well read The Egypt Game again. This book is all about Toby and his miserable life and it's not at all about a game. I enjoyed reading about the game in The Egypt Game, and was very disappointed that The Gypsy Game didn't have one. That's why the title doesn't make sense. It should be retitled "Toby and his Problems." It would be much more accurate. I really didn't like the ending. It seemed as if the author didn't care what she wrote as long as she got the book done. If you haven't read either of these books, read The Egypt Game. It's not worth it reading The Gypsy Game.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
17 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Oh well., April 3, 2005
Wow. It's downright depressing when an author rejects her own instincts, and I really get a sense that Snyder rejected a part of herself to write this book. She wrote something the felt she OUGHT to write, not something that she genuinely wanted to write, and as a consequence, this book is about what kids ought to do, rather then what they actually do, or what is truely important to them. I can really tell that the Egypt Game was inspired. But Snyder has since decided that her first book was too frivolous. Or at least it seems like she has. In The Gypsy Game, Snyder tries to capture the essence of growing up. The kids move away from imaginative play and assume responsibility in the real world. But this is a ham-handed, teen-lit sort of way to finish things, and it truly devalues the original Egypt Game. It's as if the author believes that the children's game, and by extension the children's lives, were mere precursors to real life, and adult life. She says that imagination should give way to obligation. This is a great way to describe the story, but it is also applies to the series itself. The imaginative Egypt Game gives way to the Gypsy Game, which is a book Snyder thought she ought to write, just to educate the nippers. Edifying fiction is rarely good fiction. I think imaginative play does lead to adult responsibility, but it's effects are subtle. In fact, extended, consistent imaginative play usually produces a lot of artists, and...writers. Snyder condemns herself with her own book. She forgets that things don't have to have a moral to be enriching. A children's game can slowly help kids become responsible adults. A book for the sake of itself can help kids grow. In most cases, it's imagination that makes kids responsible and compassionate. They can't reject one to find the other. Imagination and responsibility must both occur simultaneously. GRRR.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Yeah, what was THIS supposed to be?, September 5, 2003
A Kid's Review
'The Egypt Game' is one of the best books I've ever read. So naturally, I was anxious to see what was next for the kids. If anyone knows their pop music history, this is like 'Bad' following 'Thriller'. It just isn't in the same class as its predecessor. It took the author about 30 years to release this "book", and the time span is painfully obvious. It's like looking at different people. And this whole deal with Toby running away? And when do they ever play the game? My edition of 'The Egypt Game' gives two sample chapters from the Gypsy game, and it looked good to me. I was sorely disappointed. This book places with 'Gigli', 'Star Wars Attack of the Clones', and 'Bad' as one of the most pointless pieces of garbage on the face of this Earth!!! But judge for yourself. Don't say I didn't warn you.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|