Customer Reviews

HP39GS Graphing Calculator

5 star:		(10)
4 star:		(6)
3 star:		(4)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

This calculator is just what I wanted and needed. I have owned top of the line graphing calculators from HP, Casio, Sharp, TI, etc., but overall I like this one almost the best due primarily to its simplicity and ease of use. I like it especially for trips and outside activities when I can do quite useful mathematical explorations that I don't normally have time for at home or in the office with my busy schedule. It was designed by HP and teachers, first and foremost however, as an aid in teaching HIGH SCHOOL students mathematics in a very user-friendly manner.

PROS:

1) It is simple, fairly light and quite fast (75 MHz clock speed), algebraic equation operating system (EOS), but not with HP RPN, but not bad for the money since the hp 39gs units are now on sale for $63.99 compared with $59.99 for the new HP 35s for example which is a great machine, but which is totally outclassed by this much more versatile unit. The hp 39 gs is now about one year in production having replaced the 39G+ with a much better designed keyboard, etc. as described below and has evolved through 3-4 flavors from the original HP 38 of about a decade ago).

2) Very well organized analysis activities using special Aplets with about a dozen available with the unit and many many more on the world wide web (or you can write your own since programming is also available on the 39 gs). These specialized Aplets include analysis of functions, parametric equations, the famous HP solver system, statistics, etc. (with least squares curve fits available for about a dozen types, such as cubic, exponential, power law, logistic or even a user defined type, etc.!). The unit also has about 200 kb of available RAM and about 1 Mb of ROM for the operating system which is a lot more than the more powerful hp 48gII for example.

3) It will supply three types of analysis for every problem, namely a numerical table of values, a graphic plot (only two-dimensional types however) and a symbolic analysis which is only completely possible for the simplest Calculus cases (polynomials and basic trig, logarithmic and hyperbolic functions). Nevertheless, it also does numerical differential and integral Calculus and it can even supply a Taylor series approximation for your functions. It can also display a fine split-screen view (side by side) supplying a table of values as well a plot which is also very useful (with many useful zoom options).

4) It also handles some advanced mathematical functions (including hyperbolics, etc.) and of course can be used to analyze complex numbers, lists and matrices and can even take the square root of negative numbers directly in a very straight forward manner (unlike the HP 35s)!

5) It also allows the user to make detailed notes and sketches and also interfaces very nicely with a PC using the USB cable supplied with the unit for exchanging information. It also has an RS-232 (serial) as well as an infrared transfer option available as well.

6) It comes with a well written and well organized 314 page users manual and with an even more advanced manual available on the supplied CD.

7) It has a new Flash ROM so that the calculator can be electronically updated if new EOS software ROM's are produced by HP without changing out the hardware.

8) Date and time is always available with the on-board clock (using the DISPTIME command)

9) The unit has a totally redesigned keyboard that has quite an excellent feel to it (unlike the fiasco's connected with the HP 49g series for example and even better in my humble opinion than the revered HP 50g now in production for over a year too which I also own). The overall unit seems to be very well made and should last a very long time too. As always, the calculator special self tests are excellent and are triggered by simple keystroke commands. Also, Typing RULES or AMIGOS in "Home" produces two "HP easter eggs" of people who were involved in the design and production of this great system.

10) It has a completely scrollable operations history in HOME (unlimited within the available RAM memory and also easy to erase when extra memory is needed) that is very easy to manipulate by using the Copy command to recall previously evaluated expressions in order to perform quick "what-if" analysis, etc.

11) It is also very intuitive to operate in my opinion even without HP RPN. It is a great start to get students and teachers interested in doing more math and science too which is a very good thing considering recent trends in North America.

CONS

1) The batteries only last 65 hours according to HP. I can't confirm this fact as of yet, but it uses 4 AAA batteries as well as a common Lithium battery to be used as a backup while changing the main batteries.

2) It is quite thick in comparison to other such calculators and in spite of the supplied high quality slide-on cover (a maximum total 1.22 inches thick with the cover on for protection), HP should have supplied a good case for further protection as has been its standard for many other of its calculators (including the HP 35s). Why just imitate the other manufacturers with a slide-on cover for its only protection? HP has always gone its own way in this field considering how few people really understand or actively use RPN logic every day (which I have previously always preferred for many years now). Most of us now have easily accessible computers and compilers to do most computing tasks. I usually use a calculator at work only to carefully check intricate computer calculations, but when I do I want it to be simple and easy to use, especially since I don't use it every day.

3) It will not analyze ordinary differential equations as the more advanced calculators can now readily do. Also, the statistical applet correlation coefficient provided is only for a linear curve fit (regardless of the fit assumed). The relative error is provided instead for both the linear as well as for any of the other curve fit options.

4) Hopefully its sister calculator, the HP 40gs (with a full HP Computer Algebra System-CAS) for UNIVERSITY LEVEL will also be released in North America soon. HP has recently combined efforts (as of early May, 2007) with a company in Oregon to use the 39GS and 40GS for routine laboratory measurements at high schools and at universities in the very near future.

Every positive thing mentioned about this calculator in other reviews is correct, and I completely agree with them. It comes with a well-written and detailed manual, and the calculator itself is very user-friendly and has many useful functions that make the TI-84 seem prehistoric in comparison.


However, this calculator is not reliable at all. HP does not support this product anymore. There is no warranty of any kind. The last date it was manufactured was 2006, if that says anything.
After a little less than a year, the HP39gs started freezing randomly. The only way to unfreeze it is to remove the batteries. Now, the calculator will not start at all. I have my AP Calculus exam in a month and everything I have learned to do on the HP39gs must be re-learned on a TI.
I have tried talking to HP tech support about it, and that is a nightmare in itself. You will spend hours trying to figure out how to fix an issue if one arises, and I don't think it's worth it. Also, if you purchase this calculator, expect to be on your own during any math class when the teacher explains how to do everything using a TI.

I'd rather pay 100 dollars more and get the TI-89 Titanium than have to go through what I went through with this calculator.

I really like my HP 39gs. It's a good calculator, that I bought for a reasonable price, and it has a really good keyboard and screen. HP continues to make fine calculators and I must say that it does its job rather well.

The learning curve from my old TI-83 SE was a bit steep at first, but as I used the thing, I got used to it and now it's hard for me to use any other model of graphing calculator. The OS is good and intuitive, and working one's way around the keyboard is straightforward enough that I don't need any help with it, not even the manual it came with.

That said, the connection software only works with Windows, an issue since my main computer is a Power Mac G4, and since my portable is a PowerBook these days. Not that there's that much software out there for HP calculators, as compared to TI models -- there's even more stuff for my not-permitted-in-most-classrooms TI-89 than there is for my cherished HP 39gs out there on the Internet -- but I'd still like to be able to save data from the calculator to my Mac without any trouble.

So if you own a PC or don't need to transfer data from your calculator to your computer, this is an excellent buy.

I bought this calculator because it is almost $100 CHEAPER than a TI calculator and it basically has all the same functions just you have to learn them. I did not want to shell out a hundred and something dollars for a calculator so I purchased this one for around $40.

Like I said this calculator has all the functions as one of those TI calculators, just you have to learn how to use them.

The only downside is that in a class full of people who have TI's, it is sort of hard to get help how to enter certain things because you have a different calculator.

There are also a couple of improvements that I wish this calculator had, but so far so good! I recommend this to anyone who is looking to save money!

Love this calculator, although it's complicated to use if your use to the Texas instrument calculators. It's really good for its price and i would recommend it to any college student or high school student for that matter.

This calculator is worth every penny. It is easy to use, and contains all the functions/abilities that my son needs in his math classes. It can be used with a computer to increase the functionality. It was a great deal!

I purchased this for the symbolic capability. The manual is clean and the exercises work. It is easy to understand and a short time is required to learn each capability. The Manual impressed me. Many manuals are poorly written, not written for any audience, contain critical errors, in short, not really intended to be read.

I have another calculator from HP that is a graphing calculator it had no printed manual. It has a steep learning curve as a result of the PDF manual where many examples simply do not work. This machine actually gave me the required information to do some work with the older calculator.

The symbolic function has many limitations. The one I do not like is the limitation of ONE character per variable. This limits the work you can do where two character variables are used to help you know what they are.

Otherwise it is a great machine.

The calculator is working well but it is hard to understand because I have never used a graphing calculator before.

I am very pleased with this graphing calculator. I had to buy one for my grandson for school to use in math class. Everywhere I looked they want 50.00 all the way up to 150.00. I did not want to purchase it for that price so I went on the internet and found this one on amazon for only around 30.00. At that price it is doing what he needs to do for his classwork and if it gets lost or stolen I have not invested an amount that will break me. Thank you amazon.HP39GS Graphing Calculator

I am not a really proficient calculator user, however, I've managed to break 2 Ti-83s in the last couple of years. The HP seems better built to me, not by much but... I also find that its easier to use than the Ti stuff. I have learned how to do more things with this calculator and learn them more easily in a couple months than I did with either of my 83s.