57 of 58 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent PDA. Not-so-excellent phone., February 25, 2008
This review is from: HTC Mogul PPC-6800 Phone (Sprint) (Wireless Phone)
When I recently decided that I was tired of printing my schedule out each night and toting a hardcopy with me, the obvious answer was to get a convergent device that integrated PDA functionality with cell phone functionality. After a fair bit of research, I bought an HTC Mogul for a couple reasons: WiFi connectivity to the web, Microsoft Windows Mobile for reliable synchronization with Outlook, a large touchscreen, and a slide-out keyboard to name just a few.
On paper, this device was hard to beat. The design just seemed to incorporate everything I wanted - or thought I wanted.
Unfortunately, while the concept of this device is terrific, the execution had some gaping holes. I used it for about a week, and then gave up and sold it on eBay.
Here's why:
* Phone Dialing: As I said in the title, the Mogul is a really nifty PDA that makes a really, really good electronic daytimer. But it isn't a very good phone. Sliding out the keyboard to dial a number was very cumbersome, and using the touchscreen was maddening. No matter how big the screen is, it is still too easy to press the wrong digits as you dial. So, you either reach for the stylus, which is a pain just to dial a number, or you get used to hitting the backspace key a lot as you type a wrong digit, erase it, and stumble your way through the supposed-to-be-simple process of dialing a phone number. A big drawback of a touchscreen is that there is no tactile feedback to tell you if you have pressed the key. At the end of the day, the process of dialing the phone - one of the most basic things that a cell phone should be good at - was unnecessarily cumbersome.
* Bluetooth: Many of the reviews on the Mogul comment on the poor quality of the Bluetooth. In my experience, they are right. I could hear other people just fine, but the converse was not true: they always complained about the quality of my voice. I read elsewhere that the device shares the same antenna for WiFi and Bluetooth, and this creates problems when both are in use. I don't know if it is true or not, and I don't recall whether there was any marked improvement in the Bluetooth audio quality when the WiFi was off versus when it was on. I just know that the Bluetooth quality was almost always marginal and the ability to talk handsfree is very important to me. I talk frequently on the phone from my home office for business and I like to have my hands free for other tasks. I can't tell you how many times I had to rip the earpiece out of my ear in disgust to just hold the phone up to my mouth so others could hear me. Like that particle the vacuum won't pick up, you keep running it over and over the carpet to give it "one last chance" before finally giving up and picking up the crumb by hand. That's how it was with the Bluetooth on this phone. You keep giving it "one last chance." I don't know about you, but when I call people, they want to hear more than "can you hear me now" 15 times in a conversation.
* Voice Command: This phone is advertised as having voice command. Perhaps if you get it directly from HTC this is true. But if you buy the Sprint version, this functionality has been turned off and you are limited to the older voice tag functionality where you have to use your own voice to record tags for each number or command that you want to launch with voice activation. Sounds OK - until you realize that those 200 numbers in your phone book mean recording 200 voice tags, which takes a lot of time, not to mention memory space. But then comes the real rub: when you try to actually use the voice tags to dial numbers in hands-free fashion when wearing your Bluetooth earpiece, it never - and I mean never - works. Now, imagine the anticipation of being able to use this phone when you are driving, and realizing that it just ain't gonna happen. You pull over, yank out the stylus, dial the number, merge back into traffic and...busy signal...no answer...wrong number...etc. Do that twice and it is two times too many. Ultimately, this lack of handsfree capabilities was the show stopper that caused me to sell the phone rather than keep it. As an aside, there are two kinds of voice activation capabilities in cell phones these days: voice tags and voice command. Voice command is true voice recognition software, similar to the unattended answering systems that many help desks and customer service lines use these days. You know... "press or say 1 for sales, 2 for technical support, 3 for questions about your billing, ..." It recognizes any voice. On the newer phones with voice command, you can say things like "call John Smith...mobile" or "call John Smith...home" or "call 555-1992" and it will WORK, whether directly into the handset or into the Bluetooth earpiece or when using the speakerphone. For whatever reason, the Mogul's implementation of the voice tag recognition features were just not robust. If I have to speak directly into the handset rather than an earpiece, the whole voice recognition thing is sort of a moot point.
* Integrated connector: HTC uses a connector that they call ExUSB, which basically combines audio, charging, and sync functions into a single connector. The unique connector design means that you can plug a standard mini-USB cable into the device for charging and synchronizing to a PC, or can connect headphones that use the proprietary ExUSB style format. The connector on the device is designed to accept both. They also provide a splitter that let you use conventional 2.5mm headsets while simultaneously plugged into a charger or while sync'ing. I thought it was a rather elegant solution, but I really would have preferred two independent connections on the device: a 3.5 mm headset jack and a conventional mini-USB. This was not a big dissatisfier, but rather a minor annoyance to have to carry an extra "gizmo" with me when I wanted to use standard earphones with the device (my ears don't do well with earbud-style headsets...I prefer over-the-ear).
So, as I said, the main dissatisfiers with the Mogul were aspects related to its functionality as a phone. I don't know about you, but I was hoping for something that was a rock solid phone and a pretty good PDA. What I got was a rock solid PDA and a very iffy phone.
But enough of the bashing. Let's talk about what I DID like in this device.
* Intuitive GUI: Because it was a Windows device, the user interface was very familiar. Didn't know quite what to do next? Right click. Expecting the organizer to work like Outlook? It does...because it IS Outlook. Want to open and read WORD docs or EXCEL spreadsheets or even open PDFs from websites you are accessing? No problem. It all works flawlessly. It is basically like having a pocket sized version of your most frequently used desktop tools with you. I did not have to constantly refer to the manual because it was all pretty familiar territory for those who have used Windows for any length of time on their desktop.
* Media Player: The media player was pretty much just a scaled down version of its big brother desktop version, Windows Media Player 10 or 11. And, contrary to what I was told by the HTC help desk, it does support microSD cards larger than 2GB (and Sprint? Don't even go there...their ability to answer simple technical questions like "how large of a memory card can I use?" or "will the microSD slot support the newer SDHC format?" was abysmal). Turns out the device will work with SDHC cards just fine and I corresponded with several people that were using 4GB and 8GB memory cards with no problem. Translation: you can put an awful lot of mp3s, photos, messages, and files on 8 gigs. There is little need to carry a second device like an iPod for multimedia anymore. Also, I really liked the fact that accessing the microSD card was so easy on this device. I now own a Blackberry Pearl and it is considerably more cumbersome to insert and remove the microSD card. As a result, I never remove it unless absolutely necessary. That was not the case with the Mogul and when I wanted to add files, I just took the microSD card out, inserted it into the std. SD-sized adapater, plugged it into my PC, and used it as a removable drive. Super easy.
* Touchscreen: While I did not like the touchscreen for dialing phone numbers, it really was pretty slick for most of the other PDA functionality. Frankly, I found it easier to type most of the time just using a "soft" keyboard that displayed on the screen by pressing an optional menu command than to slide out the keyboard tray and start pounding away with my thumbs.
* Widescreen: There is a nice feature that automatically changes the screen orientation from vertical to horizontal when you slide out the keyboard. But you can also select this manually even when the keyboard tray is hidden. The generous screen size was nice for "day at a glance" functionality when I wanted to see previews of all my appointments for the day, all my tasks, missed calls, e-mails, etc. on a single screen. It was also nice for surfing the web.
* WiFi: I bought this device primarily to use in my home and in my office, both of which have WiFi. Since I don't have an internet data plan with my phone service, it was nice to be able to surf the web for free wherever WiFi was available, whether my house, the plant, or the local Starbucks. This functionality also allowed me to connect to our corporate intranet easily, something that would have been tough using over-the-air internet service from Sprint. At minimum, it would have meant having to tunnel into the corporate intranet using VPN all the time.
* Flexibility: Because this thing is - at heart - a computer running Windows Mobile, there are plenty of geeks out there that have been able...
Read more ›
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
40 of 40 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great Overall Smartphone, September 10, 2007
This review is from: HTC Mogul PPC-6800 Phone (Sprint) (Wireless Phone)
This is my second smart phone and I love it. My first was the Palm Treo 700wx which well served it's purpose, but I wanted more. The Mogul is of a comparable size to the Palm and if I were to consider a difference, the Mogul is actually slightly smaller. I love the fact that the screen is quite large and has the auto adjusting feature for "two-way style texting" or Sprint Network browsing/email. The design feels solid as far as the general case and buttons. I hold the phone in my left hand and am able to maneuver the scroll wheel and many of the buttons easily (tough to reach the center navigation piece for scrolling left, right and selecting a highlighted functions single-handedly).
The camera function leaves something to be desired though I've not run it fully through its paces. The few shots I took with it all lacked definite clarity when viewed on the display screen and the edges of objects and people had what looked to possess a motion haze even though they were static. The reason seems mostly related to bright light as there is a tendency toward much more defined shots in low light. The microSD card is a nice addition especially with the larger memory cards out now in micro format (just don't forcibly inhale or sneeze while handling it).
The keypad function is not as easy to operate as actual buttons. It requires patience and some amount of focus to accurately hit each number but it's not as though it's unusable...simply pull the car over if you need to make a cell call. What I do like about the keypad function is the number of options available prior to and during a call as well as the display of my last call automatically. The only additional option I would like to see is a button to turn on the Bluetooth radio during a call. Reason being, I prefer to turn off the Bluetooth radio while it's not in use because of the battery drain but if you get a call, it's tough to turn on Bluetooth while in-call.
Navigating the software is intuitive but opening and switching is slow to very slow depending on the specific application. The other thing I would have liked to see is the "real" internet on this device. I like the capabilities with Windows Live (viewing email, MSN messaging, etc.) and POP3 email connection seems to work with Gmail but I've yet to be updated on email from Yahoo.com. The Wi-Fi does make a positive difference in loading speeds and the Bluetooth radio is more compatible with my Motorola HS850 headset compared to the old Treo 700wx (clear voice and good volume both in and out-going).
All in all I'm happy with the upgrade and I think most other discerning users will be happy with the Mogul too.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
25 of 25 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Phone works great after I installed the upgrade, February 1, 2008
This review is from: HTC Mogul PPC-6800 Phone (Sprint) (Wireless Phone)
I've had my eye on the sprint mogul for quite some time. I've read the reviews posted here and at other sites. Here are my thoughts:
1. Should you buy the phone, thoroughly check it out w/i the first 30 days. That way should you not like it you can return it.
2. If you are experiencing any problems with the phone go to: http://www.america.htc.com/support/mogul/software-downloads.html and see if you need to install the latest upgrade. Though I purchased my phone in January 08, I had to install the upgrade, which has been available for at least 6 months. This fixed my bluetooth isssue as well as several other issues.
3. Try this website for helpful info about the phone that's not in the user guide, I found it very useful: http://www.america.htc.com/support/mogul/tips-tricks.html
4. To save battery life, I have turned off the wi-fi and beaming. I also put the screen in "sleep" mode when I'm not using it. This has extended my battery life greatly.
5. "softboot" the phone when it's convenient for you. I have never had a problem with the phone locking up but I read a review that suggests soft rebooting several times a week to clear cache...So about twice a week I do a soft boot when it's convenient for me. I normally do it 1st thing in the morning...I know it's a temporary fix but by rebooting when it's convenient for you, you won't have to reboot when it's inconvenient.
6. Try the Sprint software store http://softwarestore.sprint.com/ for add-ons. Some of them are really good.
7. In case you don't know, when you close an application/option, it's not really closed. it's running in the background. To really close it, go to Start/Settings/System tab/Memory/Running Programs tab...from there you can truly close the application/option. The sprint store also sells applications that will truly close the application w/o you having to do the extra step.
I hope my review is helpful. The ones I read were informative to me. In the end, you have to make the best judgdment call for you.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No