Most Helpful Customer Reviews
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A good quick read., November 24, 2009
Half world was a good quick read, kid friendly and enjoyable. The book did have a Neil Gaiman feel to it, but I really wished it was longer and a little more involved with the characters and story backdrop. I found the environment in the book to be quite cool, but not detailed enough and also felt the same with some of the unique and fun characters within - the book just lacked a little depth. It brings forth this wonderful place and just kinda skims the surface of what's there and those that inhabit the land.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
a refreshing story, a believable heroine and an odd yet delightful world, January 30, 2012
This review is from: Half World (Hardcover)
Pros: A fascinating mythology
Interesting cast of characters
A believable heroine
Teaches valuable lessons Cons: A few times the plot tended to be predictable
The introduction could have been done better I wasn't quite sure what to expect with Half World but after reading the prologue I quickly got into the story. The prologue tells of the three realms: the Realm of Flesh, Half World and the Realm of Spirit. I was quickly captured by the idea of these three realms. Though the introduction after the prologue put me off a bit because the dialogue and the characters seemed two-dimensional and I believe the author could have done it better. It wasn't very consistent when you compare it to the later chapters which were written fairly well. I sympathized with Melanie and thought her character was believable and well done. She wasn't a heroine right from the beginning but rather grew into the role, gaining courage later on. The other characters where just as interesting to read about. And it's interesting to note that Goto did quite a few female characters compared to the males. Haven't you noticed a lot of times, especially in fantasy, there is a wise and kind old man but never a woman. But in Half World, we had Ms. Wei, who I have to say is my favorite character and I really enjoyed how she spoke in third person all the time - very lovable! Although a few times the plot was predictable, Half World was still a wonderful read. Half World was such a bizarre place and Goto described it so vividly. A delightfully original story and I'm excited to read the sequel, Darkest Light, to dive back into the world and see what's in store next. If you want a refreshing story, a believable heroine and an odd yet delightful world then make sure to check out Half World!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
not your typical YA fantasy, hurrah!, January 11, 2012
This review is from: Half World (Hardcover)
This book moves at a dead run. There are two prologues, one distant past and one recent past. The first is a pared-down legend-backstory, but the second is grab-reader-by-throat.
Then the story proper begins, as Melanie's mother goes missing, and she gets a phone call (on a disconnected phone) from the deeply-creepy Mr. Glueskin telling her what she has to do if she ever wants to see her mother again. Because the reader has already encountered Mr. Glueskin in the second prologue, this is even creepier than Melanie knows.
Melanie makes a believable young heroine, sometimes frustrated and overwhelmed, sometimes hasty and resentful, but always picking herself up and 'doing what's nearest'. She has no special powers, only determination and a loving heart--a refreshing change from the YA heroines who are billed as kickass tough girls but are passive and helpless when the crunch comes. (And hoorah, she is a chubby kid and does not become magically thin-and-pretty by the end of the story.)
The horrors she faces in Half World aren't cheap blood-splatter special effects, but subtler and weirder. I thought there was an influence both of the Japanese ghost scrolls and of the Buddhist hells, and maybe also Stephen King's Overlook Hotel, which is to say, pretty damn creepy.
So yeah, if you haven't read this book already, you should go and read it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|