We picked up this book, late in 2008, and after viewing the DVD that was included with it, and reading about some of the restaurants featured in areas that we sometimes travel, a few of us have made it a point of sampling the burgers at many of these restaurants....
In all instances, we ordered and sampled the burger that was described in the book, and to date, we've only been to restaurants in the "South" - Texas, Arkansas, Tennessee, North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia etc.... We still have so many more to visit..
The fun part for us is making a trip to these locations, and seeing / sampling what the author wrote about in the book.
[...]
Considering the states I've listed above, three stand out...
The best so far is from Cotham's in Scott, Arkansas. Great Burger, Great Ambience... and Great surroundings. This one has to be seen and tasted.
A close second is Char-Grill in Raleigh, N.C. Very good.
Third is in Fort Worth - At Kincaid's...
We can't quite understand why Dyers on Beale in Memphis made it in this book... it's just not up to par with everything else we tasted. We went there twice in different months, to make sure we just didn't have a bad day... The second visit confirmed our thoughts of the first visit there.
El Camino in Austin was also a bit "typical" and did not meet the mark of our expectations.
We'll continue trying to visit (and photograph) the Hamburger America locations and sample their burgers... It's a great guide, with a lot of fun places to visit. But by all means, it's not a listing of the best there is...
That's a bit disapointing.