The leash appears to be well-made and sturdy. The leather has attractive 'ridging' and quality seems to be somewhat better than the dog leads from the discount stores. I gave it 4 stars primarily for value, and also I was hoping the color would be more distinctive. However, the color is pretty close to the standard brown, and I've given the "generic" type leather dog leashes pretty tough use over several years without failure. Overall, not that much to distinguish from less expensive leather leads, although I know dog owners who have had quality dog leashes for multiple generations of pets - maybe it will ultimately pay for itself.