Customer Reviews

Hamish MacBeth - Series Three

5 star:		(11)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

Hamish Macbeth is a tremendous series. I am sadden, however, by the fact that there is only the three seasons. This is the third in the series and the shows presented here have quite the serious tone to them compared the the first two seasons. The highland humour is still present as the undergirding for the shows but much of what is here is just good drama. We get to see a side of Hamish, and the other characters, that weren't so obvious before. The season does go out on a high, but slightly weird, note regarding two of the characters' relationship as well as a shocking premonition coming true. This is a must have for all fans of the good folks in the wee village of Lochdubh.

I bought this DVD on a whim and I am so glad I did. Just wish this series had gone on longer. The stories are fun and the scenery is wonderful.

The third and final season of Hamish MacBeth wraps up the storylines and characters we've come to know in wild fashion. The series should have lasted longer. Robert Carlyle (PC MacBeth) is an outstanding actor and, if there was any justice, he'd be getting big parts in great movies.

While the DVD's are very enjoyable, they are disappointing to someone who has enjoyed the novels. Outside of the title, they have very little to do with M.C. Beatons books, so don't look for the residents of Lochdubh or even Hamishs girlfriends. Cute is about all I can say, a pleasant watch

We like these programs very, very much. They incite all our emotions; from humor to tears and the story line is cohesive but varies from show to show and is never tiresome, old or predictable. Sometimes the heavy Scottish brogue is hard to catch but mostly what little of the chat that I don't understand is not vital to following the story. The Scottish scenery and towns are beautiful, the variety of personalities are charming and, except for a villain, lovable, entertaining, and unforgettable.

I have enjoyed Hamish series and I am sorry that there were not more made. The 3rd series (season in the US) provides a chance for them to tie up some things from previous episodes. Without giving anything away the series ends on a sad note but a happy note also. If characters with a definite Scottish flare and a little strange twist are for you then this is right up your alley.

I'm a huge Hamish MacBeth fan, and when I found the third series to the set I couldn't wait to see the episodes. I wasn't disappointed. The series does take a jog from the familiar fun first two series and becomes a bit darker. But I found the story lines very well written and captivating. The characters were still fun but perhaps a bit more mature as if settling into their respective parts like a well worn pair of jeans. Like I said the third series was darker, yet even funnier than the first two. Overall, I loved all three series, but the third season was my favorite.

My family and I (husband, 13 year old boy and 10 year old girl) all enjoy the Macbeth mysteries. There is a lot of humor in the characters. We have found that this series (more so than 1 or 2) has more "adult" topics but it's not obvious enough for us to be overly concerned about our daughter watching it. My husband and I find the village a lot like Northern Exposure--interesting characters, lots of local color.

This show is one of the best on BBC America. It's a shame it ends with this series. The characters are so enjoyable.

Just love the series but am a "wee" bit dissapointed in the abrupt ending. I know Hamish and Isabelle get together in the end but you want for more! Wish they would have made a " Reunion Special"? That would have been nice. Adore the scenery, the tartan plaids and the local folk. And of course, Jock! Everybody wants a "Westie" ?