Customer Reviews

Hamish Macbeth - Series Two

5 star:		(9)
4 star:		(4)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(3)

 

 

"Hamish MacBeth," a British Broadcasting television series based on characters created by the Scottish woman author M.C. Beaton, and set in Scotland, had its American tv premier in 1999. It's set in a small village, Lochdubh, in the Scottish highlands, big sky country of mountain and loch, populated by eccentric, country-music loving characters, men who drink hearty, wear kilts-- surprisingly often, considering the climate, and gorgeous hand-knit sweaters. It's nominally a mystery series, though some of the mysteries are mild, indeed, and it's just full of surprises. You'd have to call it a village cosy mystery, I think, not the slightest tartan noir flavor to this one: minimal blood and violence, although lots of welcome slightly bent humor.

Biggest surprise to me, the starring actor, Robert Carlyle, raised in Maryhill, Glasgow, Scotland, rather a young man when this series was made; his trademark intensity greatly subdued. He plays the title character, Hamish MacBeth, the local law, who finds himself bending the law as often as he enforces it. It's not a town to run by the book. Carlyle, who first caught the wider public's eye as "Gaz" in The Full Monty; generally plays things deadpan in "Hamish Macbeth", leaving the breathtaking scenery unchewed: he's ably supported by an excellent cast, a cute Westie terrier, and the flavorful great outdoors.

Plots vary from the complex to the simple, and are frequently shot through with that sly subversive Scottish humor: they also occasionally feature the supernatural. One episode is about an older woman, walking on the beach by the loch, who accidentally steps on a live World War II land mine, and cannot step off it until it's disarmed. MacBeth, who's come down to the loch to drown himself, must instead rescue her.

Several episodes in this series are credited to Danny Boyle, who has gone on to greater things on the bigger screen. One, in particular, deals with the (fictional) rough Scottish equivalent of the Irish Blarney Stone, supposedly used for centuries in the coronations of Scottish kings. It's been taken some centuries ago by the English, and is currently on display in Westminster Abbey, London. A number of the local lads, wearing their kilts, of course, so they'll blend right in, liberate it from London and hide it by a local waterfall. Pleasurable chaos ensues. Chief among the pleasures of this episode is the supposed long-lost brother of one of the more important supporting cast characters. This long-lost brother has had the most remarkable bad luck in his attempts to live a life of crime, and has lived most of his adult life in jail: most recently an Argentinian one, a life not likely to be pleasurable to a Scot. He has also had remarkably bad luck in regard to accidents and injuries, and is as close as he can come to a bionic man without entering the realm of science fiction. Yet he steadfastly, furiously, refuses to admit he's had bad luck. So his nonexistent bad luck finally, in this particular episode, bites not only him, but also his brother, Mac Beth's right-hand man.

Now I love mysteries, generally the bloodier the better. But the Scottish, positively non-twee charm of the Hamish Mac Beth series wins me over. So try it, you might like it.

I now own series one and two of this fabulous series. What a pleasure it is to watch really interesting and engaging stories suberbly acted by a cast that make it all so very believable - well almost. And what a delight the Scottish scenery is.
Without going into the story lines I would simply say that these programes are well worth watching, and well worth spending a hard earned dollar on! Like Monarch of the Glen and Ballykissangel, you can't go wrong.
Sadly, we now have to wait until the third series comes out. Perhaps Amazon could speed it up a little :)

Last year, I purchased Series 1 of Hamish Macbeth and loved it,and when Series II became avaiable decided to purchase it. It's just an enjoyable show to watch with interesting characters and sometimes goofy plots and stories. Would I suggest it to others? Yes,if you liked Northern Exposure, you may like Hamish MacBeth.

Hamish Macbeth is a brilliant series... notably Scottish with a hint of Northern Exposure flavor. The interplay and depth of the characters is amazing... the storylines are humorous with a great perspective on human nature... there is constancy, mysticism, passion, trust, and mystery in every episode. Series two keeps building the story. Every episode has me wanting to move to LochDubh and joining the village folk at the pub for a pint!!

Contrary to previous posters lament on offensive material, this could be nothing further from the truth. Our family has learned to love this Scottish town and the people in it... We laugh and talk about the twists and always want to see more... We can't wait for the third season to come out!! Every now and then we pull out the discs and start watching!! Makes the bad weather outside all go away... and our hearts are warmed by the expereince!

Buy Series 1 and 2.. then start looking for the third!! I'm trying to collect the hardback books... just can't get enough!!

For us, the series really took off in set 2. The story lines are dark and far more complex than the original set. This was, for us, a much more involving show the darker it got.

I like Robert Carlyle since seeing him in Full Monty. I like the way he plays Hamish, and i really like Hamish's deputy, He really makes this show fun. the girl could be anyone, but the local oddballs make this show fun. I have read 3 or 4 of the books, but if you just watch the show without a preconcieved idea of how Hamish should look and act, you will enjoy the show for the fun of it. Just like alot of the british comedy. Sit back and get absorbed.

How could they leave me hanging. When will season 3 come out. Love the setting and the wonderful people. Just like a small town anywhere in the world. Life goes on, rolls around and comes back to you. Lovely people and wonderful Series. Come on season 3.

I thoroughly enjoyed this series when it was first aired. I even visited the village of Plockton where it was filmed during a visit to bonny Scotland. Watching it again many years later proves the plot and storyline are enduring and well written. Each episode is a self contained event with larger drama running across the series. The scenery is stark and beautiful and the characters highly individual and entertaining. Finally Hamish himself who is happy to live in a small regional centre and be left alone to act out his extended boyhood has some lessons for us all.

This is a fantastic program with humor, compassion and a wee bit of mystery. The facinating landscape and the common day life foibles make it hard to choose one favorite character, beginning with the darling Westie and including the powerful performance of our beloved Robert Carlyle. It is a must for the followers of the genre.

The Hamish Macbeth series is fun, although the episodes don't follow M.C. Beaton's novels accurately. The Series 1 and Series 3 DVDs that I ordered seem fine, but the Series 2 DVD set was defective -- the first of the two DVDs wouldn't play on several players I tried. Amazon handled the returned item well, and sent a replacement, but that one had exactly the same defect -- the first DVD wouldn't play! So, I sent that one back too and requested (and received) a refund. I went to BBC America Shop and bought "Hamish Macbeth Series 2" and it worked just fine. So, I had to pay a higher price for the item from the alternate vendor but at least I finally got a DVD set that worked. As far as the stories, they are well-written and well-acted and I recommend them for fun and enjoyable viewing. The characterizations and plots are different than those in M.C. Beaton's books, though.