Most Helpful Customer Reviews
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Others have tackled this subject better, but worth reading, June 19, 2000
This review is from: Hand of Prophecy (Mass Market Paperback)
Maybe. Other reviewers have given the gist of the plot, but I don't agree with their ratings, that's why I review this book. LeGuin in Four Ways of Forgiveness has written better about slavery and how it destroys the owned and owners. Octavia Butler in The Kindred writes better about the sexual relationship in slavery between owned and owner. In that book there are outsiders who make it easier for us to empathize. Many of Samuel R. Delaney's books are about unequal sexual relationships. I prefer his too. I liked Hallie in this book, but Frenna was too distant, too strange, ultimately an unsatisfying hero, for me. Troah was too too scary to also be sympathetic, as I think she was supposed to be, eventually. In my opinion, it is worth reading, if you don't expect too much from it. And you've read the others first.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
'Blade Runner' meets 'Spartacus' only 10 times better.., June 3, 2000
This review is from: Hand of Prophecy (Mass Market Paperback)
I bought this book on the strength of its blurb alone, yet what the book contained blew all parameters of my expectations into orbit. I doubt if i've read a book that weaves the genres of sc-fi and action/romance/historical together so well. Park's gender reversal (her trademark) gives light to some wonderful female characters; from Troah who is determined to exact her revenge on those who have betrayed her, to Hallie the blonde Amazonian warrior whose armour is as strong as her compassion (I've never been so worried over a character's survival when Hallie's fighting Rampage) and onto the protagonist herself Frenna who looks so fragile it seems she will break at any second but shows more determination than anyone else in the story. The whole slavery angle was addressed perfectly and leaves a thousand oppotunities for sequels or follow on stories. Most importantly the whole love side of the novel was delivered in a way saying: 'it doesn't matter who you love as long as they love you'. We can see how that backfires for Althea and Leiban, and how despite the loyalty the boundaries of 'slave' and 'free' still dominate the lives of the characters in the book. This is good route on Severna's part because it stops love obstructing the slave/non-slave relationship and prevents a novel that balances passion with survival from turning into a 'love conquers all' romantic epic. Basically, this is one of the better books I've read this year and probably THE best sc-fi book I've ever read. Severna Park manages to combine strong characters, painful anticipation and occasionally obtuse humour to create a book that this reader won't be forgetting in a hurry.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
I recommend this, liked it even better than Speaking Dreams., November 23, 1998
This is the second of her books that I've read -- perhaps there are only two. The first, "Speaking Dreams" I think is the name, takes place in the same universe and may even share a minor character. It is not necessary to read them in order, though having the first as background was surely helpful. I liked this book more than the first. It seemed tighter, less grim, and I thought it had more appealing characters. It was a real page-turner and adrenaline-rusher, with a complex enough story to keep me from figuring out how it would come out. And the characters were believable, the dialogue reasonable -- in short, nothing got in the way of a very nice read. One basic premise of the story is that slavery is somehow an accepted part of this future civilization, which otherwise is not too different from ours. There's a people that "developed" slavery with some genetic and biological aspects such as a virus that keeps a person from aging and enhances healing for twenty years, then kills the host when the virus runs out of steam. The slavers are now the pariahs, but the general structure of slavery remains, with a lottery feeding the slave population. This was a really scary idea: anyone in their late teens was eligible to be "selected", that is, turned into a slave and stripped of their rights and previous life, treated as property for twenty years, then to die a horrible death. The other basic premise of the story is that there's a "cure" for the slave virus. This story follows various characters as the word gets out about this cure. It's easy to imagine a subsequent novel exploring the social consequences of this cure, and I'd love to see it. This is kind of frustrating because all this says nothing really about the story or characters. There's a runaway slave who learns a lot about herself, her people, and her relationship with the slaver peoples over the course of the story. There's a fascinating description of a troupe of gladiator slaves, including the warrior Hallie who was my favorite. And there's the prophet herself, a very intriguing character. Tons of interesting, strong, complex, believable female characters. I recommend it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
