to, flaws and all. (Interesting aside: 2 of the reviews shown for this book are actually about her perfume book and her metal toys book. Pay attention, I am happy to give this book 3 stars, but this is based on the photos alone. I love all purse books and enjoy finding a photo of a vintage bag I've not seen before. However, this book is full of inaccuracies. Some Collins of Texas bags are identified as Enid Collins bags. There is a big difference to collectors; anyone halfway knowledgeable about these bags knows the difference. Ouch, I even cringed to see an Enid bag shown with the original leather straps replaced by metal chains, then represented as original when, in fact, the bag has been butchered and ruined. A few bags are placed in the wrong time period. There is a celluloid bag identified as bakelite, a ridiculous mistake in my opinion. In addition, there are some purse she calls lucite that actually were produced in the style of lucite handbags but, in fact, are a cheaper non-lucite plastic. It makes a big difference in pricing and desirablity. And speaking of pricing, take all of her price guides with a huge grain of salt. I have collected, bought, and sold lucite handbags for nearly 20 years ([...]) and know them cold. Her prices are wildly all over the board. She either had bad advice or just plain guessed. Many are priced way too high, some are even too low. This is an ongoing problem with appraisers; they simply do not have enough precise experience with these bags and the actual marketplace to be accurate. I think the problem with this book is the age old problem: Judith knows a little bit about a lot of things (she produces so many collectible books about so many unrelated subjects), but is not an expert on any of them. At least, if she's an expert on some type of collectibles, it's definitely not vintage handbags. In addition, the layout which makes you turn the book sideways to read what she's written about each purse (correct or incorrect as it may be) was very annoying. Still, I love the photos and, as an avid, passionate vintage purse collector, I must have every book on the subject. If you feel the same way, you'll have to have it people.)