Most Helpful Customer Reviews
42 of 45 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Comment from the Author, December 1, 2002
This review is from: Handcrafted Soap (Paperback)
This book was originally 178 worded pages. North Light has a fixed format of 128 pages total. I am sorry to say the pertinent things soap makers had asked me to write about was was edited out to make room for pictures and melt and pour including the reason I call olive oil is a neutral oil. I was referencing the effects oils have on softening or it having the ability to reverse the softening power of oils, such as, sunflower. Much of the book is out of context. I was not given the book for review until 30 days prior to printing, and the charts not all for review, so there was no time for North Light to correct anything. I have, however, posted explanations and corrections that I feel need to be made in the second printing on my soap list, especially the Lye-Water Chart correction.....
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
17 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Easy, Fun and Accurate, May 29, 2005
This review is from: Handcrafted Soap (Paperback)
If you want to make hot process soap in the easiest and most reliable manner you can find this is the book for it. This book, and author, are truly amazing. Finally a soap book with easy instructions and color photos for visual learners! Photos througout for slow cooker, double boiler and oven cooking
methods, as well as, the finished soaps.
This book does away with much of the repetative rhetoric that is in every other soap book (warnings about essential oils, naming what some of their properties, etc., as this is can be found online. She gets down to the business of How To Do It along with extras usually NOT seen in other books, such as: including an Oil Property chart so you need not get online to
recall what an oil does, EO blending so that you know the formula of how to blend top,mid and bottom notes, and she even explains briefly what each major fatty acid in oil might do for a bar of soap in the (edited) soap designing section of the book.
On a personal note I joined Ms. Boone yahoo group. She is the only author I am aware of that invites her readers to a group, to email her or ring her with questions. She truly cares for the soap making success of her readers and group members.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great Book But "Fluffs" Over Some Topics, November 16, 2002
By A Customer
This review is from: Handcrafted Soap (Paperback)
I love the pictures and the way the information is presented and would buy it for that alone... I double checked some of the recipes and found the lye amounts to be correct. I especially liked the authors way of incorporating milk into hot processed soaps. I would definitely purchase this book again.... YET!!! I thought her introduction was a bit negative and less than motivating about the joys of soapmaking. Her comparison of Cold-Process to Hot-Process was a bit negative also. I also don't agree with the authors information about oils.. I feel there could have been more research done. She mentions that Olive Oil is a "neutral" oil... I definately don't agree! I have found it to be very "active" and conditioning. And, due to the low iodine content, Olive Oil effectively makes a rock hard bar upon curing. The Oil Characteristics guide was misleading to me also...A waste of my time. I have found Canola Oil to be highly conditioning to almost that of Olive Oil. There is very little mention of curing the soap. Crock Pot temperatures vary along with the abilities and experience of the individual soapmaker. Most hot-processors make soap and let it cure about a week, unless they've tested for neutrality. She doesn't mention a whole lot of testing for this or even viable PH ranges for handcrafted soap. Because of this, I question the ability to make the soap that day and use it later that same day. I would personally increase cooking time a bit to insure soap neutrality. But again this is all my opinion! I did like the book because there is so little out there focusing on the hot-process method. I would purchase this again, and feel it's one for the library, yet don't think it deserves the 5 stars because although an experienced soapmaker would be able to fill in the informational gaps, I wish there was just a bit more for the "new" soaper. I'm a tough judge yet still rated this book pretty darn good!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|