Most Helpful Customer Reviews
3 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent Book By Captivating Writer, April 23, 2010
This review is from: It Happened in New York City: Remarkable Events That Shaped History (It Happened In Series) (Paperback)
I originally picked-up a copy of "It Happened In New York City" because I've really enjoyed other works by the author Fran Capo. She has a great way of captivating the reader with an imaginative and clever style.
I'm from New York but I have to say I was totally surprised by some of the events I read about. That made it a great read and very hard to put down. This book gave me the educational and entertaining feel of the History Channel, only better...much better.
I highly recommend it to anyone interested in traveling to New York or learning about this great city's past. Kudos to Miss Capo once again!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
"IT HAPPENED IN NEW YORK CITY" WOW! WHO KNEW?, February 17, 2010
This review is from: It Happened in New York City: Remarkable Events That Shaped History (It Happened In Series) (Paperback)
"IT HAPPENED IN NEW YORK CITY" By Fran Capo and Art and Susan Zuckerman , Is an absolute delight!
Not one of your run of the mill history books, this book is filled with Pirates, gangsters, a romantic triangle that became the crime of the century, from a secret subway to Tammany Hall, this book has it all!Giving a backdrop to the flavor, people and places of one of the most iconic cities in the world.
Written in a wonderful smooth narrative fashion, I felt at any given moment the characters might leap off the page and become part of a Martin Scorsese Film. So informative and entertaining I had to finish the book in one sitting. I highly recommend this book to those who dare go behind the scenes of what really did "Happened In New York City".
Nancy Lombardo Host: COMEDY CONCEPTS BLOG TALK RADIO
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1.0 out of 5 stars
Not worth Your Time, January 29, 2012
What a disappointment. I am preparing for visitors to NYC from three countries and was hoping to share with them some interesting stories about the City that they may have not otherwise heard. Unfortunately, for the most part, this book is not a source for those stories. The title, It Happened in NY begs the questions So What, to which this book has no answer. That these events happened in New York doesn't make them interesting or certainly not Remarkable.
Jenny Lind, a Swedish opera singer is featured in one story. She had an amazing voice but was also generous and donated a significant portion of her earnings to NYC charities. OK, that was nice but certainly other talented musicians throughout history have also donated money to charity. That she made as much as she did was probably the better part of the story but little other info about her life is presented. Victoria Woodhull accepted the nomination to run for president (before women had the right to vote). Anyone familiar with women's history in the US would be familiar with Ms. Woodhull. The story includes a brief reference to actions taken by Ms. Woodhull and her sister that, today, would be considered insider trading, actions that funded her candidacy but also increased the wealth of the famous Vanderbilt family. Now that would have been an interesting story to explore but, alas, it is only given a sentence or two. The first plunge of America's first polar bear club gets a few pages...not much to it really. I am sure the author missed the opportunity to list a number of famous New Yorker's who were club members throughout the years. Very few of the stories presented actually have "shaped history" as the subtitle states.
The first story presented is probably the best and most noteworthy. It centers on the history of plight of the first Jews to come to the New World. This group of 23 Sephardi Jews were part of a larger group fleeing Brazil in the 1600s after the region was seized by the Portuguese and persecuted. Sixteen ships of Jewish refugees fled the region, made found safe passage to the Netherlands but one ship was blown off course by a storm. After being set off course, the ship was attacked by pirates (literally of the Caribbean). Hoping for some pirate booty of their own, a French shipped "rescues" the captives only to hold them hostage in New Amsterdam. There, a group of charitable settlers held an auction to pay what the French wanted to save the captives...and this small group of Jewish refugees started the first synagogue in the New World that remains an active community of worship to this day. There, now you have read the most interesting story in this slim volume.
I should have had a clue about the lack of substance in the book when it was noted that the author is a writer for the Guinness Book of Records, interesting factoids but not really ones that shape history...and this book certainly isn't nearly as much fun to read as the Book of Records.
Take a pass on this scant volume.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|