Most Helpful Customer Reviews
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
FDR - The likely, but not foreordanied candidate..., August 6, 2004
Franklin Delano Roosevelt. The very name conjures up images of a Great President, a great governor, and a great man who overcame physical challenges to become that great leader.
In his final book, Steve Neal has given us the story of the 1932 Democratic National Convention, where FDR was nominated for President for the first time.
Neal does a fantastic job of giving us biographical sketches, including political philosophies, of the contenders for the nomination, and then dives right into the excitement of the convention itself.
FDR may have been the leader in delegate count at the start of the convention, but that did not mean he had the nomination all wrapped up. Unlike today's conventions, Democratic conventions prior to 1936 required a 2/3 majority to nominate the candidate. FDR did not have a 2/3 majority when the convention opened, thus necessitating his political operatives to wheel & deal in order to secure the nomination.
It is this political wheeling & dealing that makes the book so wonderful & readable. The back room efforts with Ritchie and Baker, and the deal made with John Nance Garner that secured the nomination for FDR are given ample attention in this book.
I found that I had a terribly hard time putting the book down once I started reading it. It is well written, and an absolute must read for any FDR afficinado.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Engaging look at FDR and U.S. Politics, February 19, 2005
This is a gripping narrative of the 1932 Democratic Convention in Chicago, which nominated Governor Franklin D. Roosevelt (FDR) of New York for President. Today Mr. Roosevelt (1882-1945) is widely recognized as a great leader, elected four times despite having polio, the man who launched the New Deal programs that changed America and who led the USA through most of World War II. But here we see that the front-running Roosevelt was on shaky ice at the 1932 convention because candidates then needed a 2/3rds vote for the nomination. FDR faced powerful opposition from former nominee Al Smith, house speaker John Nance Garner, Governor Albert Ritchie, Newton Baker, and other powerful figures. Of course, Roosevelt had strong allies, including Louisiana's notorious Huey Long, plus key advisors Louis Howe and James Farley. The author describes the strengths and weaknesses of the major players, setting the stage for the drama that unfolded. Readers also see how FDR's lieutenants offered Garner the Vice Presidency in a near-desperation move after the third ballot that worked and kept Roosevelt's coalition from unraveling. All this occurred at a convention where Democrats knew they were likely winners against President Hoover in November due to the onset of the Great Depression.
Author Steve Neal is political correspondent for the Chicago Sun-Times, and he's written a superb narrative. Some may question whether FDR's coalition at the 1932 convention was as tenuous as Neal suggests, but few will fail to be engaged by this remarkable story.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
When Conventions Still Mattered, August 29, 2004
I read this book in the midst of the '04 convention season, and welcomed the journey back to a time when political parleys actually meant something.
The late Chicago journalist Steve Neal (he passed on in February) recounts the '32 Chicago convention that propelled FDR on the path to the White House and immortality.
FDR's nomination was no sure thing, despite his entering the Chicago convention with a strong majority of delegates. Indeed, Neal shows how close FDR came to being denied the nomination, as past Democratic frontrunners like Champ Clark (1912) and William McAdoo (1924) had before him. At the time, Democratic candidates needed to amass two-thirds of the delegates to cinch the nomination -- a threshold that assured Southern states a voice in the selection of a candidate, and made for protracted, multi-ballot fights (more than 100 in '24) and brokered conventions. FDR abolished the two-thirds rule (replacing it with a simple majority standard) and only two subsequent Democratic conventions went past the first ballot.
An eclectic cast of characters loomed large in the machinations that secured FDR's nomination -- for example, Joe Kennedy and WR Hearst, who cleared a path for Cactus Jack Garner to be given the VP slot; Huey Long, whose support was ironic in light of The Kingfish's later vitriolic attacks on FDR, and Big Jim Farley, FDR's brilliant campaign manager. But no one played a more central role than McAdoo, Woodrow Wilson's son-in-law and Treasury Secretary. No fan of FDR's, he swung the deeply divided California delegation into the New York Governor's camp at the decisive moment. This deft maneuver thwarted the ambitions of FDR's bete noir, Al Smith (who had foiled McAdoo hopes in '24) and McAdoo's old nemesis Newton Baker, who was the likely beneficiary of a deadlocked convention. (At one point, FDR offered to throw his support to Baker.)
This book takes its title from the FDR campaign's theme song. But I was surprised to learn that "Happy Days Are Here Again" was actually a substitute when the original theme song --"Anchor's Away" (paying homage to FDR's stint as assistant Navy Secretary) -- was deemed too subdued for the raucous Chicago partisans.
Political junkies looking for a short reprieve from the '04 presidential sweepstakes would do well to pick up Neal's new book. It'll transport you back to a time when political conventions still mattered.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|