Most Helpful Customer Reviews
48 of 49 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Hardy Bamboos... a Worthy Library Addition, May 12, 2005
This review is from: Hardy Bamboos: Taming the Dragon (Hardcover)
As a relatively ignorant gardener on the topic of bamboos, I was looking for a good book for gardeners (opposed to scientists) on the topic of bamboos to possibly incorporate into my temperate garden (Central PA, USDA Zone 6). Comparing this book to 'Bamboo for Gardens' (A highly recommended book based off of other customer reviews as well as several online bamboo nurseries), I found this book to be a much better read for the temperate gardener than the former.
In 'Hardy Bamboos', Paul Whittaker tells us many wonderful and personal stories about his experiences growing bamboo. I find highly personal accounts such as this a joy to read because they bring gardening to life. Furthermore, these firsthand experiences really help in the bamboo plant entries. Although 'Bamboo for Gardens' does provide sufficient information on the culture of each bamboo (i.e light requirements, max. height, min. temp. hardiness, etc) 'Hardy Bamboos' goes even further. In each entry, Whittaker also includes a pencil sketch to more specifically describe the overall habit of each bamboo (i.e. tall and stately vs. tall and arched, etc), measurements from his garden regarding actual bamboo height and spread at different ages as well as numerous observations that he's made reguarding specific varieties over the year. These details and measurements made this book more useful for me than 'Bamboo for Gardens' with regards to figuring out how a bamboo will grow and look in my garden. However, I should point out that 'Bamboo for Gardens' goes into much more scientific background on bamboos and includes both the temperate and tropical bamboos. Because of this, I find that 'Bamboos for Gardens' makes a better overall bamboo reference book.
But for those of us who live in temperate regions and wish to learn more about how to grow bamboos outside in our gardens, I found 'Hardy Bamboos' to be the better, more garden-detailed book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
38 of 40 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Simply the best Bamboo Book so far...., April 22, 2005
This review is from: Hardy Bamboos: Taming the Dragon (Hardcover)
I began studying and growing bamboos in 1992. Back then there was virtually no books on bamboo which were up-to-date, comprehensive, and interesting from the point of view of a plantsman or garden designer. After a hiatus of 7 years living without bamboos and not seeking books on them, I have returned! And just in time!!
Published in 2005, Paul Whittaker's book, Hardy Bamboos: Taming the Dragon, has come out just as I have returned to my former love. I could not have had a more welcoming and helpful book to greet me.
This book is not just a compendium. Or an encyclopoedia. Or chatty, folksy bamboo book for little old gardeners. It is the magnus opus of an inveterate bambusaphile who is also an accomplished plantsman and landscape designer and gardener. Bringing all these abilities together, Paul has wrought a fantastically interesting and very useful book for any bamboo-aholic.
I was especially impressed with his first-hand knowledge of the temperate species and his ability to communicate this knowledge in a very personal yet also professional way. This book could easily have been called 'Adventures in Bamboos with Paul Whittaker'!
I can't recommend this book highly enough. After so many years sans bamboos, I was fortunate to find this tome upon my return, as if it had been written for me and was just waiting for me to find it!
Breck Breckenridge, Spokane
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
17 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Hardy Bamboos: Taming the Dragon, January 9, 2007
This review is from: Hardy Bamboos: Taming the Dragon (Hardcover)
In the subject matter this book gets five stars. The author did an excellent job explaining the different types of bamboos. However, if you live in the South, this is NOT the book to purchase. I only wish that the author have considered the people in the South.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|