Most Helpful Customer Reviews
45 of 51 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
70% of these reviewers do not honestly critique this book!, April 30, 2004
By A Customer
This review is from: Hating America: The New World Sport (Hardcover)
Isn't great to choose sides either liberal or conservative and then state your party line instead of providing an honest critque of this new book by John Gibson? I felt that the book gives very clear and factual information backing up the claim that many in the world hate America, and a good explanation as to why this is. If you want to sum up the "why" we are hated into one or two words or sentences (like a good many of the Amazon reviewers have opted to do) you will miss some real insight and perspective on this complex and emotionally charged subject. Do I believe (almost 35 percent of the reviews here) that the author misses the point that the world hates George W. Bush instead of the American people and therefore the book is a garbage read and only worth a one star review? No! Do I believe that there are a lot of people that are envious of the wealth and power that our country has been blessed with and has worked very hard for? Yes, they are out there. And this book brings the attitudes and mindset of these individuals into greater clarity and understanding. I see this same attitude almost every day here my city. People that see someone that has "more" than them, and hating them because of it. The fact that many are willing to kill someone because they are envious is a story that has been replayed time and time again throughout history. Hey, if your mind is made up, I don't want to confuse you with the facts! This book looks at the issue with a certain measure of political bias (Gibson is a Fox news conservative journalist) but I feel it is worth reading for it's perspective and attempt to shed more light on the "America Haters." Knowing the "why" of a particular matter is an important first step in DOING something about it. Gibson provides well researched arguments backed by solid sources which form a strong foundation for his conclusions. I welcome reading a different book from the liberal side that deals with this same issue. If it exists, I haven't found it yet. I liked the writing style, and found that like LA LAKERS guard Kobe Bryant, Gibson could be misunderstood for being a bit of an egotist. Oftentimes people that are passionate about something (basketball in Bryant's case) can be misperceived as being arogant, when in fact, they are simply exceptional at what they do, or highly knowledgeable about the subject. Gibson impressed me as being the later. As for the reviewers who saw Hating America as essentially a political sales pitch, I don't see many of you providing suggestions for alternate books which deal with this subject from a non political perspective. If someone would like to provide some titles, I would gladly give them a read. To sum it up, not a flawless book, but certainly worth a four star review.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
147 of 190 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Read It!, June 12, 2004
This review is from: Hating America: The New World Sport (Hardcover)
I'm Australian, and like most Aussies I grumble about America from time to time. But, and also like most Aussies, I know it's the best, most successful, most intelligent, most humane, most cultured and most admirable society on Earth, the true beacon of human achievement and the light and inspiration of the world. Yes, for all its faults which I know all about. I am, it is true, half British. Modern British envy of America saddens me, as the envy-and-nihilism-intoxicated ravings of the loathsome, freakish Margaret Drabble and Harold Pinter and their likes fill me with utter disgust and shame. As an Aussie, I, like most people in the developed world, owe my high standard of living directly of America and I know it. Not only because of American inventiveness and marketing. Nott only because America saved our bacon in world War II and ronald Reagan saved us from the threat of nuclear annhilation more recently. The American alliance allows us to keep our defence spending down to 2% of GDP. We loaf at America's expence, let it pay for two-thirds of our security, resent it, and scream for help when we're in trouble. We're not as bad, not as envy and inferiority consumed, not as neurotic and self-hating, as the French and Germans, but we could be a lot better, and yes, more grateful. The Poles and people in Eastern Europe don't hate America. Their liberation by America is close enough in time for them still to remember it. One word of advice to Americans: You are loved, you are admired, by people all over the globe. Don't forget your friends, and perhaps give them a bigger word of praise than you sometimes have in the past. America attracts more resentment because its culture tends not to acknowledge its friends than for perhaps anything else. Read this book to understand one of the most dangerous, sick and disgusting pathologies in the world, and help do something to stop it. God Bless America!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
24 of 29 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
I call 'em like I see 'em..., April 16, 2004
This review is from: Hating America: The New World Sport (Hardcover)
Excellent reading (unless you're a flaming liberal). You might also like Anti-Americanism by Jean Fracois Revel.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|