Customer Reviews

Hauppauge WinTV-PVR-150MCE Personal Video Recorder (1042)

5 star:		(42)
4 star:		(14)
3 star:		(7)
2 star:		(4)
1 star:		(7)

 

 

This is among the least expensive hardware capture cards on the market (if not THE least expensive). The video quality, performance, and usuability are great with or without Windows MCE. I happen to use this card on my XP Home system and did not have any problems during installation or otherwise.

This is a "Hardware-based" capture card. Which means that the card comes with hardware onboard that handles all of the processing to convert your TV signal to a file on your computer. Software-based cards use your CPU for this. The advantage is that with a hardware based card you can actually use your computer while recording as the CPU usage is minimal (I actually don't see any CPU usage on my machine), compared to a software card which uses almost all of your CPU. This also means that you can use an older or slower computer to watch/record TV without suffering any performance issues. In the past, software cards were much cheaper than hardware, but Hauppauge's line has brought the cost down so that now there really isnt a reason to choose anything but a hardware card.

The MCE version of Hauppauge's PVR-150 differs from the "regular" non-MCE version because it does NOT come with *ANY* software other than drivers and it adds an FM radio tuner. The regular version comes with a remote and software to control the PVR-150, but no FM radio. There is only one TV tuner so you can only watch or record one channel at a time.

Since the 150MCE doesn't come with any software, you will have to control it with another program. Windows MCE can do this, but if you have XP Home or Pro you will need to use 3rd party software like BeyondTV and SageTV, or free ones like the open source MediaPortal. Since the card outputs MPEG2, you need to have installed a DVD player like Intervideo WinDVD or Cyberlink PowerDVD in order to watch TV (decode MPEG2). If you have an Nvidia card, you can use Nvidia's PureVideo Decoder which gives probably the nicest picture. Note that decoding (watching TV or your recorded movies) does take up some CPU, about 10% on my computer. If your computer came with a DVD player or burner you likely already have this software. And if not, most DVD burners come with it, so if you don't already have one you can get a DVD burner for around $50 and get the software thrown in.

For those with quality issues, check with the software you are using and try to increase the bitrate. This will lead to less "artifacts" (looks like a bad JPG), and smoother video. Obviously the filesize will increase per recording, but hard drives are so cheap now that you can afford to get a bigger drive to accomodate. You will have to adjust the settings to find what is an acceptable compromise between filesize and quality. Just for reference, I usually record with a variable bitrate with an average of 5000 and a max of 6000 which lets me fit about 2hrs on a DVD. In your decoding software adjusting the interlace method also gives good results (choose from bob, weave, or both). I rank the decoding software as Nvidia PureVideo, WinDVD, PowerDVD from best to worst as far as quality goes, but it is really a matter of personal taste.

Other options to consider are obviously the regular PVR-150 which adds software and a remote (but you lose the FM radio), and the PVR-500 which comes in both regular and MCE versions as well. The PVR-500 has two tuners so you can watch one program and record another or record two shows at the same time which is very nice. Just like the PVR-150MCE, the PVR-500MCE comes without software or remote control, but adds an FM radio. FYI, the PVR-500 is essentially two PVR-150 tuners on the same board, so quality is the same. There is also a low-profile version of this card.

I'm using the pvr 150mce with my home-built computer with p4 3.0, ati radeon 9600, win xp mce 2005. i connected my analog cable TV signal into the pvr 150 ... and i could not get a picture. then i went to the hauppauge website to download the latest driver (which has support for win mce). then there was an error saying that i didn't have the dvd decoder software. i downloaded power dvd 5 and windvd 6 to see which offered better picture quality. finally, i could watch tv and play dvds on the computer. windvd 6 gave better quality, making the picture quality about the same as cable tv on a regular tv.

in summary, if you don't mind tinkering a bit (eg, downloading drivers and installing new software), you'll be very happy with the end result. i also have tivo downstairs with a regular tv. mce 2005 is very slick, in some ways the menus and interface is slicker than tivo. however, tivo is still a bit more user friendly. for example, when fast forwarding past commercials, then hitting play, tivo will automatically start playing at a point several seconds before you stopped fast forward, knowing that people will overshoot the commercial. mce 2005 doesn't have this important feature.

PROS:
Installed under Windows XP MCE in less than 10 minutes.
Picture quality is pretty good (using S-Video feed from my satellite set-top box).
Drivers installed with no problem at all and I was able to pause live tv as well as record TV programs.

CONS:
As an audio fanatic, I hold great value to good quality of sound and unfortunately, this is where this card failed my criteria.
As a satellite subscriber, all my audio is wired with optical cables and coax cables. This guarantee the delivery of digital audio accross the entire system as satellite is 100% digital.
for some reason this card (and actually all TV cards) offers 2 RCA inputs for audio. This means that whatever you record is converted to 2 analog channels - NO DOLBY DIGITAL
I wonder why they are not using the audio card on the pc as a resource for the audio. most pc's today comes with digital audio input.

CONCLUSION:
While I would love to see TV cards with digital audio input I think for this price this card is an excellent value.

There's another detailed review by "Harvey Ramos" named: "Great Low Cost Option, November 1, 2005" that you may want to read as well.

P.S: This is the Windows XP Media Center Edition version of the card. You must have all your hardware (video card, CPU, Remote control etc..) supported by Windows XP MCE, otherwise this card will not work correctly.
Also this version comes with no remote control (the assumption is that you already have one) and a fairly simple installation guide.

If you run linux and want to use this card... google for IVTV and enjoy. This card in addition to MediaMVP make for a media center of unparalled quality.

Have fun.

I bought this card as the second card on my MythTV. This card works very well in Linux Fedora Core 5. It doesn't have a remote control. If you want a remote control with the card you will have to buy the full version of the card. This card is meant to be used for Windows MCE and for this reason doesn't have a remote included.

I was so exited when this was finally in stock and delivered. I installed it right away, but after the drivers were installed my CPU usage would shoot to 100%. (I have a new Dell 8400, with P4 3.0, 2.0GB DDR ram, blah, blah, a GREAT PC). Anyway, I unistalled, reinstalled, changed PCI slots, nothing!!! MCE would not recognize the card was there.

To make a long story short, I finally reformatted (since I had only recently purchased the PC and was not losing much). I installed the card right away and worked GREAT!!~! I then began installing my software, 1 by 1 making sure they did not interfere with the TV tuner.

When I got to my Dazzle DVC II capture device drivers, BOOM!! same thing happened, unistallation of these drivers corrected the problem. So I had located the source of the problem.

But it went deeper, the Hauppauge drivers for the PVR-150MCE can not be installed in th same operating system as almost ANY other capture device drivers or software. Pinnacle Studio 9 even states on there website that it will not work with Hauppauge devices.

I found a work around by creating a Dual operating system with MCE 2005 (for the TV Tuner etc) and XP Home Edition (for my video capture).

If you are using a seperate capture device and like your current configuration (ie you do not want to use the PVR for analog capture for home videos etc,) then you have some serious work cut out for you!!

Overall a great card, minus the workaround needed for my situation

I was so unsure about buying a tv card, but ireally wanted one, so i was researching them for a few months and finally got the courage to buy this one. Let me tell you it does everything i had expected, i have windows Vista home premium and MCE picked it up right away, didnt even use the disk. Works flawless for me, definitely would recommend!

This component saved me from turning my HP Pavilion 1230n into an expensive doorstop. I couldn't find any other tuner card that would work with Windows XP MCE. It does EXACTLY what it says it will do, and it does it problem-free. It was easy to install (hardware and software) and has performed beautifully. I would highly recommend it for anyone running Windows XP MCE for an OS.

Having used other PVRs over the past several years, I decided to try a Hauppauge device. Their devices have an excellent reputation. It was my intention to use the 150MCE with Vista Beta2. However Vista Beta2 and the 150MCE do not work well together. I used the drivers that were on the Hauppauge website that were marked for Vista. The Hauppauge software does not work with Vista Beta2(it will not install!); the Microsoft Media Center software locks up the computer so tight that the only cure is to pull the power plug; maybe the "real" Vista will have the problem fixed upon release. The 150MCE works very well with Windows XP. In fact it is outstanding; both the FM portion and the cable TV portion work extremely well under XP. The 150MCE works better than any of the other PVRs that I have used in the past. Picture quality is excellent; sound quality is very good both in the FM and the TV portion. Now having used other products, I would purchase other Hauppauge products to use in other projects.

This card works nicely; Hauppage cards tend to play well with others. However, the anti-aliasing of this card is poor, poor, poor. See http://techreport.com/reviews/2005q2/tuner-comparo/index.x?pg=10

Most of the people here that say that the card has good picture quality have probably never tried another card. If you want good picture quality, go with another tuner.