From School Library Journal
Grade 3-5–Hazel Green is back, and in trouble as usual. This time she has overheard the powerful lawyer, Mr. Davis, yelling at her building's kindly custodian, telling him, I don't like
you and I don't like your
kind. In an attempt to make Mr. Davis feel guilty and apologize, she sets a scene in which she shouts the same words at her friend, the Yak. She is overheard, but instead of making Mr. Davis repent, she gets herself banished from the big building party. Ultimately, with the help of her friends and her own courage, she finds a way to unmask Mr. Davis for who he is and shows everyone what really happened. The slightly choppy text, meandering story, and heavy-handed moral are unlikely to bother young readers, who will be rooting for the protagonist all the way. Hirsch's quirky main characters are interesting and likable, and Hazel and her friends are fairly well rounded. Unfortunately, many of the secondary characters tend to be two-dimensional, and Hazel's parents are rarely seen cardboard cutouts. However, the author's descriptions bring the settings and situations alive, and Hirsch infuses the story with humor and a fairy-tale feel. Libraries in which
Hazel Green (2003) and
Something's Fishy, Hazel Green (2005, both Bloomsbury) are popular will likely want to add this one. Others looking for fun, easy adventure stories will find it a nice addition, but not a first purchase.
–Amy Lilien-Harper, The Ferguson Library, Stamford, CT Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Gr. 4-7. Hazel Green shows her mettle by standing up for her convictions. This sequel to H
azel Green (2003) and
Something's Fishy, Hazel Green (2005) revolves around an incident in her apartment complex. When Hazel overhears her officious neighbor Mr. Davis shouting at the kindly custodian Mr Egozian, "I don't like
you and I don't like your
kind," she decides to shame Mr. Davis into confessing his fault. Her plan backfires, though, putting Hazel in an uncomfortable position and leaving Mr. Egozian as vulnerable as ever. Clearly this thoughtful novel would be an excellent choice to spark a discussion of ethnic prejudices, but it's the series' original characters that readers will find most engaging: the stubbornly truthful Hazel, her mathematically brilliant but socially challenged friend the Yak, and Marcus, who adores Hazel but doesn't really understand what drives her. First published in Australia, this unusual novel unfolds mainly through the main character's thoughts and conversations. Readers who enjoyed the earlier books will welcome this involving story about quirky, strong-minded Hazel Green.
Carolyn PhelanCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved