Customer Reviews

Is He A Girl? (Marvin Redpost 3, paper)

5 star:		(8)
4 star:		(6)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(4)

 

 

I'm Ceci. I gave this book four stars because it was very funny,mysterious, and it made me keep on reading. I didn't give this book five stars because the ending doesn't really answer some questions in the book. Some parts of it made me laugh until milk came out of my nose. Kids: DON'T TRY THIS AT HOME!!...Altho you SHOULD probably buy it.

I have read all of the Marvin Redpost books, but I liked Is He a Girl? best because it was very fun and suspenseful. It is a fun story because Marvin thinks he is a girl but he doesn't tell his friends. He believes that he is starting to like girl things but I think that there is no difference in girl and boy activities. I think Marvin sees this too. I think this is a fun book for eight or nine year olds to read and younger kids to listen to.

I teach second grade and used this book as a read-aloud for my class. The students loved this funny book and I will definitely be reading it again next year.

were do I start. Marvin is a great book. When I was reading it I felt like I was watching a great film.My favorite charector is General Jackson.It realy made me think about how other kids feel when they get teased.It is a short chapter book but when your reading it, it makes it seem a long time Louise sachar does not leave any details out.

I liked Marvin Redpost because it was funny . The reason it is funny to me because he kept trying to kiss his elbow. He almost got caught kissing his elbow. He started to act like a girl . He was wondering why girls giggle when they come out of the bathroom. He liked the way girls did thiings with their hair. He started to bite his finger like a girl in his classroom. He said that girls are lucky because they can wear anything they want like shorts, skirts and dresses and get to get boys in trouble more than boys get girls in trouble. My favorite part was when he tried to kiss his elbow and got tangled up in his sheets.

I've read the book twice. Great book. Casey tells Marvin that if you kiss your elbow, you will turn into a girl. At first, Marvin doesn't believe her, but when Marvin kisses his elbow, he thinks he really is turning into a girl! Very hilarious! If you like books where the character thinks that they are something else than what they really are, then you'll love this!

marvin redpost is he a girl is really good and funny! This one girl tells him if he kisses his elbow he will turn into a girl!
If you have heard about the book and the ending it is......
well, I can't tell you the ending sorry! you should read it your self!
by.
katie

Marivin is so weird.So, so,SO weird!He tries to kiss___(not telling!)You want to hear what he kisses?You find outif you want to!Raed the book! You don't have to like it but I sure did!Marvin fell off the ___.(again!)That is all I'm going to tell you!

Casey sits by Marvin at school. And Casey said if you are a boy and kiss your elbow you will turn into a girl and the same with the girl. Then Marvin had a bad dream and woke up and SCREAMING and his mother, oh I mean "her" mother thought it was Marvin's little sister Linzy but it was Marvin. I am not going to tell you what happened at the end of the book. I really like this book because the ending is so good. You should read it! By Darbi

I think you should buy this because there's lots of wierd stuff like when Marvin asked his sister, "Do I look like a girl?" My teacher said, "If you are paying attention you'll giggle." I'm like,"No books make ME giggle." But this one did. But that's just my opinion. By Katie