He Said She Said

Peter Karp (Artist), Sue Foley (Artist) | Format: Audio CD

Product Details

• Audio CD (March 16, 2010)
• Original Release Date: 2010
• Number of Discs: 1
• Label: Blind Pig
• ASIN: B0036IA6UW
• In-Print Editions: Audio CD  |  MP3 Download
• Average Customer Review: 4.8 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (4 customer reviews)
• Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #105,984 in Music (See Top 100 in Music)

Editorial Reviews

Review

He Said She Said is a unique, daring idea beautifully executed by two talented, inspired artists unafraid to express themselves in songs of love, hope, longing, emptiness and frustration. A masterpiece. --Blues Revue Magazine

Product Description

"He Said She Said" started as a simple email and letter correspondence that took on a life of it's own. The letters turned into songs and the songs coalesced into a show that chronicles an evolving relationship between two enormously talented writers and performers. Sue and Peter have previewed the show to sold out crowds at the Epcor Center (Calgary AB) and the Winspear Center (Edmonton AB) as well as many dates through the US and the response from fans has been overwhelming. The songs are by turns simple, intimate, surprising, touching, and very funny; blues-tinged, torchy and rocking.

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:

4.0 out of 5 stars CD Review: Peter Karp and Sue Foley's "He Said-She Said" (Blind Pig Records), March 22, 2010

By 

'Rebel' Rod Ames (Ingram, Tx) - See all my reviews

This review is from: He Said She Said (Audio CD)

It's been a long time since "He" (Peter Karp) left the surroundings of swampy New Jersey and the rural grit of Southern Alabama to take his equal parts "Yankee-Rebel juxtaposition", as it states in his bio, to travel across the country, bringing his unique blend of roots rock, blues, and folk music to others. His songwriting has been compared to John Hiatt and John Prine and is regarded as one of the best guitarist-piano playing songwriters in the biz. His bio also claims, "Karp repeatedly transfixes his live audiences...with impressive guitar and slide licks infused by his love of Freddie King and Elmore James".

It's also been a long time since "She" (Sue Foley) has left the safe confines of small town Canada to come to Austin, Texas at the ripe young age of twenty-one. She quickly established herself amongst the elite blues guitarist in a blues guitarist saturated Austin. She has shared the stage with many masters of the blues and Americana or roots music; artists such as BB King, Buddy Guy, Lucinda Williams, and Tom Petty to name a few. Since then she has gone on to cultivate her own unique blend of the blues-rock genre. After moving back to Canada from Austin, she won the prestigious Juno award for her critically acclaimed CD "Love Coming Down".

You put these two together and you get their wonderful new collaboration titled, "He Said She Said" (Blind Pig Records).

This album is, in my opinion, a brilliant concept record, born from letters and emails the two had written to one another over a one-year period. The letters were turned into songs telling the story of their experiences on the road, expressing the loneliness and the difficulties caused by being separated from friends and family while on the road.

The result is a set of fourteen tracks of some of the sexiest, steamiest, dramatic, and comedic tunes I have ever heard from two very different artists. There is chemistry here that I did not know existed when the two were separate acts, which they still are. However, they are touring and performing this "He Said She Said" concept to audiences all over Canada and the states to rave reviews. And it's no wonder. "He Said She Said" blends the styles of two very versatile performers who took two very different roads that brought them both to the same destination. It could have only been fate that these two were brought together.

The first track "Treat Me Right" is really all about a man and woman finding nothing but fault in the way the two treat each other, alternating back and forth treating the listener to a somewhat comedic argument between the two characters in the song -

"Well you broke down I don't believe what you said/that's what she said/Well you broke down I don't believe what you said/She said it again/I said, Honey I might be dull as a junkman's blade/I said, "Honey even a broke clock's right twice a day/why do you treat me this way?"

I love the interaction between the two often alternating sentences, not necessarily exclusive to just verses.

The entire record is laid out just that way, drawing us into these very personal letters and emails set to music; and oh, what wonderful music it is! Both musicians are extremely talented and are considered amongst their peers, let alone their fans, as two of the best blues guitarists around. There is no shortage of blues here but it's not limited to that. There is folk, twang, you name it, and it's here.

For instance, the very steamy and sexy "Mm Hmm" has a very jazzy element to it continuing the alternating of the different verses. The lyrics are - well, see for yourself -

"Wouldn't it be nice/to once or twice or even thrice/pick up where we left off to resume/Throwing each other around a room/Mm Hmm

"To hear your heavenly high pitched moans/followed by my grunts and groans/Closing our eyes and falling into the deep/with one eye open to watch each other sleep/Mm Hmm."

I'd have to say it's probably my favorite song of them all and not just because of the hot lyrics, but the entire arrangement itself. The addition of trombone and harmonica only add to the steaminess the tune already possesses, making it "hotter than a Georgia asphalt", as Lula played by Laura Dern expresses to Sailor played by Nicolas Cage in David Lynch's `Wild at Heart". It's that steamy.

You get the picture. This is a great record, absolutely not to be missed. Now, I only wrote about a couple tracks here. This is a concept album meant to be heard in order, tracks one through fourteen. It's all intertwined and meant to be heard just that way. `Rebel' Rod says see for yourself and check it out.

3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars Great on CD.Even Better in person., September 27, 2010

By 

dedicated blues fan (Massachusetts) - See all my reviews

Amazon Verified Purchase

This review is from: He Said She Said (Audio CD)

I just saw Peter Karp and Sue Foley on Friday the 24th of September. As much as I love the CD, live really explored the relationship between the two and how the songs tell the story. The CD has even more meaning and depth for me now. Here's hoping they make another CD with the tons of songs they already have written! And a DVD would be great! This is the best roots/blues/folk CD in years!!

5.0 out of 5 stars Great Chemistry, Great Album, March 20, 2011

By 

E. C Goodstein (Northern CA United States) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   

Amazon Verified Purchase

This review is from: He Said She Said (Audio CD)

I can't add much to the other reviews. I've liked Sue Foley for quite awhile, and this is a terrific addition to her discography (if ok, a little bit departure too). I really enjoy this album-- great singing, playing and songs. I like how they're able to run a gamut from trad. blues to 'roots rock' to pop to jazz--and even traces of flamenco--so effortlessly. And they really update at times Lee Hazlewood/Nancy Sinatra (and even a bit Louis Prima/Keely Smith!) so well-- without making a big fuss about it. Some may find it a little too 'unplugged': that doesn't bother me at all, and in fact I find that an advantage. A great idea, great duo.