From Publishers Weekly
High school junior Skye Johnson faces so many challenges that it's no wonder she has trouble keeping her head above water. She must knock some time off her personal best in the 200 freestyle in order to qualify for the state swimming competition, she's being pursued by a hunky football star, and she bears the brunt of the responsibility for the care of Sunny, her 19-year-old Down syndrome brother while her single mom is at work. Unfortunately, like the protagonist, the author tackles too much here. Scenes of Skye swimming and her interactions with Sunny are the most fully developed, but a subplot about Skye's boyfriend's attempt to rape her gets superficial treatment. Further complications arise when Sunny wants to take swimming lessons and ends up qualifying for the Special Olympics, scheduled for the same day as the state championship. Only a glimpse of the strength of the adult/protagonist interactions that made Rottman's Hero so compelling is evident in Skye's interactions with her mother and her swim coach. Consequently, the conclusion is too quick and tidy a wrap-up of many complex issues. Ages 12-16.
Copyright 1999 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
Grade 9 Up-Skye, a high school junior from a single-parent home, is largely responsible for the care of her older brother Sunny, who has Down's syndrome. She strives to maintain a straight-A average in her schoolwork and is determined to qualify for "States," the statewide swim competition. When the school's football star, Mike Banner, deems her worthy to date, Skye's already complex world becomes almost overwhelming. Responding to pressure from him to spend more time together, she ditches her brother and uses her newfound freedom to meet with her boyfriend. Predictably, he pressures her into sex and finally forces himself on her. She narrowly escapes, but the angry boyfriend continues to badger her and the confrontation between the two ultimately costs her the opportunity to go to States. In the end, Skye begins to mature and to think for herself. Unfortunately, the conclusion is a little too neat. Although the protagonist faces myriad problems, they are all resolved happily. Still, this is a realistic portrayal of dating and of a teenager with Down's syndrome.
Joanne K. Cecere, Highland High School, NY Copyright 1999 Reed Business Information, Inc.