From Publishers Weekly
Having chosen to set her latest novel (after Persian Nights ) in a hospital milieu (within the San Francisco Bay Area), Johnson succeeds remarkably well in replicating that world, but not so well in the delineation of character, a talent her previous works revealed in full measure. Here, perhaps, her signature ironic detachment holds the characters at too far a remove; the women in particular are passive, flaky, even silly, with no intellectual life. The doctors, too, are stereotypical, and we instinctively know that the model of rectitude will have the farthest fall from grace. The plot revolves around Ivy Tarro, an exceptionally beautiful single mother, who is admitted with a minor problem that is treated incorrectly, propelling her to the verge of death. Johnson not only knows how a hospital works, she understands the professional and social hierarchies; the rivalry between the medical and surgical services; the subtle distinctions among house staff; the crises, from the moral to the mundane; the questions of medical ethics, complicated by the availability of lifesaving equipment. (The most effective scenes are, in fact, graphic descriptions of patients being kept alive by artificial means.) The timeliness of her theme and her adroit plotting, should make this Johnson's most commercial novel; one cannot but wish, however, that the narrative were less facile and more deeply felt. Literary Guild alternate.
Copyright 1990 Reed Business Information, Inc.
--This text refers to the
Hardcover
edition.
From Library Journal
Professor, literary critic, and author of a highly acclaimed biography of Dashiell Hammett, Johnson sets her latest novel in San Francisco at the fictional Alta Buena Hospital, focusing as she has before on the lives of the privileged. Her tale of relations among Dr. Philip Watts (handsome senior physician), Ivy Tarro (beautiful patient), and Mimi Franklin (dedicated volunteer) is, except for a few explicit phrases, a romance novel: breathless and girlish in tone, too dependent on implausible plot developments, regrettably prone to ethnic and sexual stereotyping, filled with predictable female fantasies. Not Johnson's best work by a long shot, but simple and pleasant reading. Recommended for comprehensive collections of popular fiction.
- Molly McCluer, Piedmont, Cal.Copyright 1990 Reed Business Information, Inc.
--This text refers to the
Hardcover
edition.