From School Library Journal
Grade 5 Up–This husband-and-wife team first paired their talents for
The Market Lady and the Mango Tree (Morrow, 1994). This book, also based on Peter Watson's experiences as a Peace Corps volunteer in Dahomey/Benin, is made up of a series of 14 vignettes describing a young American's reaction to customs and circumstances he encounters while living in a small farming village. Some of the sketches are graphic and disturbing. In The Prisoner, a baboon is kept chained to a mango tree for no apparent reason. He is persistently taunted by the village children, and there is some question at the end of the piece as to whether or not he has mauled one of his tormentors. I thought I heard a scream, but it was probably just the squeal of the tires…. While the writing is clear and well complemented by Mary Watson's realistic paintings, the picture-book format coupled with the gritty subject matter (dog-eating, airplanes crashed into mountaintops with their passengers left inside, and the aforementioned animal torture), it is difficult to imagine an appropriate audience for this work.
–Grace Oliff, Ann Blanche Smith School, Hillsdale, NJ Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Gr. 3-5. In this picture book for older children, a white American boy visiting a village in West Africa tells how he learns from his friend Yampabou about "the mysteries and magic" of a different culture. In one- to two-page episodes, loosely gathered together as a journal and illustrated with full-page colored woodcuts, the visitor records his experiences. The boy sees both wonderful and sad things, such as a baboon chained to a mango tree. He learns that people in the village eat mice ("the one who caught it got the head"). When he expresses shock that they also eat dogs, Yampabou explains he is just as appalled that Americans eat pigs. More than separate episodes, the experiences move together toward a surprising climax: Will Yampabou find his courage by catching a lion and eating its heart? Yes and no. The friendship story will touch readers; it will also make them think about people in different parts of the world and about Yampabou's laughing comment "that what is forbidden for one is completely acceptable for another."
Hazel RochmanCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved